Discuss Celtic Player of the Year 16/17 in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.

1. DJ CJ

   Joined:

   Jan 25, 2009

   Messages:

   8,200

   Likes Received:

   1,674

   Location:

   I'm Everywhere

   Fav Celtic Player:

   Wanyama

   Fav Celtic Song:

   Let The People Sing

   Now that voting is officially open who is your player of the year?. If your pick isn't listed then please share.

    

   DJ CJ, Apr 4, 2017

   #1

2. The Greenman King of kings

   Joined:

   Jan 22, 2017

   Messages:

   2,470

   Likes Received:

   1,005

   Difficult because so many players have stood out this season but I'm gonna go with Armstrong simply because of his massive improvement this season compared to last. He is a reflection of the brilliant job Brendan has done since taking over.

    

   The Greenman, Apr 4, 2017

   #2

3. doctor venglos

   Joined:

   Jan 11, 2008

   Messages:

   11,833

   Likes Received:

   861

   I think for me it has to be Stuart Armstrong for his stand out performances for us and his elevation to the Scotland squad.
   There are some others in close contention, but I just can't see past Armstrong.

    

   doctor venglos, Apr 4, 2017

   #3

4. Pacific Ocean Blue

   Joined:

   Dec 5, 2007

   Messages:

   5,728

   Likes Received:

   819

   This is tricky!! But I ended up going for Sinclair

    

   Pacific Ocean Blue, Apr 4, 2017

   #4

5. Saul Goodman Gold Member Gold Member

   Joined:

   Jul 9, 2010

   Messages:

   19,014

   Likes Received:

   6,309

   Location:

   Dublin

   Fav Celtic Player:

   Scott Brown

   Fav Celtic Song:

   Grace

   Leaning towards Sinclair.

    

   Saul Goodman, Apr 4, 2017

   #5

   DJ CJ likes this.

6. GavCFC1

   Joined:

   Nov 27, 2009

   Messages:

   15,604

   Likes Received:

   1,537

   Between Sinclair and Armstrong for me, Sinclair just edging it I think

    

   GavCFC1, Apr 4, 2017

   #6

7. Zander Gold Member Gold Member

   Joined:

   Jan 10, 2010

   Messages:

   24,662

   Likes Received:

   7,686

   Location:

   Irvine

   * knows

    

   Zander, Apr 4, 2017

   #7

   Liam Scales likes this.

8. hakumeikirameki

   Joined:

   Jan 29, 2015

   Messages:

   2,345

   Likes Received:

   428

   Location:

   The Netherlands

   Fav Celtic Player:

   Ever: The King; Now: Leigh Griffiths

   Fav Celtic Song:

   Fields of Athenry

   All of them.

    

   hakumeikirameki, Apr 4, 2017

   #8

9. CheGuevara

   Joined:

   Jul 30, 2010

   Messages:

   17,769

   Likes Received:

   6,199

   Location:

   Ayrshire

   Fav Celtic Player:

   Danny McGrain

   Fav Celtic Song:

   Grace

   I would have voted Scott Allan, but that Messiesque legend isn't available for selection, so had to go for Dembele

    

   CheGuevara, Apr 4, 2017

   #9

   JML67 likes this.

10. JML67 Gold Member Gold Member

    Joined:

    Aug 4, 2011

    Messages:

    15,868

    Likes Received:

    19,862

    Sinclair just about pips Armstrong for me

     

    JML67, Apr 4, 2017

    #10

11. Officer Doofy Come to me, human man Gold Member

    Joined:

    Jul 5, 2011

    Messages:

    62,355

    Likes Received:

    33,194

    Armstrong
    
    Sinclair and Dembele are close, though. Then probably Tierney.

     

    Last edited: Apr 4, 2017

    Officer Doofy, Apr 4, 2017

    #11

12. Markybhoy

    Joined:

    Nov 9, 2008

    Messages:

    42,074

    Likes Received:

    3,702

    Scott Sinclair. Had him down for it about five games into the season and I've seen nothing since to change my mind.

     

    Markybhoy, Apr 4, 2017

    #12

13. Deco67

    Joined:

    Dec 11, 2013

    Messages:

    1,833

    Likes Received:

    272

    Location:

    Newcastleton, Scottish Borders

    Armstrong for me. Our second most important player after Brown.

     

    Deco67, Apr 4, 2017

    #13

14. hakumeikirameki

    Joined:

    Jan 29, 2015

    Messages:

    2,345

    Likes Received:

    428

    Location:

    The Netherlands

    Fav Celtic Player:

    Ever: The King; Now: Leigh Griffiths

    Fav Celtic Song:

    Fields of Athenry

    Tough call between Armstrong and Sinclair (I ended up going with Armstrong in the poll, though). Both have been vital players, not just in terms of goals.

     

    hakumeikirameki, Apr 4, 2017

    #14

15. TheHappyLoss

    Joined:

    Jul 14, 2013

    Messages:

    13,429

    Likes Received:

    8,709

    Location:

    209

    Certainly the most improved

     

    TheHappyLoss, Apr 4, 2017

    #15

16. Onefootwonder

    Joined:

    Jun 26, 2012

    Messages:

    9,737

    Likes Received:

    5,631

    I genuinely can't decide. Take the entire season into account and there can be an argument for Sinclair, Brown, Dembele, Armstrong or Tierney.

     

    Onefootwonder, Apr 4, 2017

    #16

17. HailHoopy

    Joined:

    Nov 30, 2015

    Messages:

    1,901

    Likes Received:

    898

    Sinclair.

     

    HailHoopy, Apr 4, 2017

    #17

18. NorwichCelt

    Joined:

    Jun 2, 2015

    Messages:

    495

    Likes Received:

    285

    Location:

    Norwich

    Fav Celtic Player:

    Current - Rogic All time - Samaras

    Fav Celtic Song:

    Willie Maley

    Armstrong, his energy, goal threat and abilitiy to shoot with either foot absolutely tremendous and only getting better, sinclair and dembele close 2nd and 3rd and tom rogic deserves a mention as he was fantastic before injury

     

    NorwichCelt, Apr 4, 2017

    #18

19. Liam Scales

    Joined:

    Sep 11, 2006

    Messages:

    81,843

    Likes Received:

    30,669

    Location:

    Glasgow

    Fav Celtic Player:

    Broony

    Fav Celtic Song:

    Celtic Symphony, YNWA, Grace

    Between Brown, Sinclair and Dembele for me. Have no idea what one though.
    
    Armstrong doesn't make the cut because he never really done it up until December odds, whereas the others have had that form all season.

     

    Liam Scales, Apr 4, 2017

    #19

    WolfOfParkhead and PaulM1888 like this.

20. Mr. Slippyfist

    Joined:

    Dec 20, 2009

    Messages:

    6,683

    Likes Received:

    9,464

    Sinky.

     

    Mr. Slippyfist, Apr 4, 2017

    #20