[Mafia] ZOMBIA MAFIA

Why did Aidan claim Bag, Cena and Summer were all clean? He was Cultist.. did he have any powers or was he talking *?

 

He may well have been recruited to mafia, but I trust his role was cult Investigator 100%

It would have been far too early to throw jc under the bus to make sense. And no one else has flipped as cult Investigator

 

I'm absolutely convinced Sean isn't town just based on how he has responded to accusations throughout the game. Doesn't seem to me like someone who has been falsely labelled. Lynch.

 

You able to quote these posts?

It might make my decision of who I target easier.

 

Forgot it was discarded actually. But he said since he was late he got offered VT or Wildcard (just like you) , and knew someone else got offered wildcard as he was told it was first come first serve

I don't see how he would have pinned jc as cult (specifically cult, not just scum) without being PI. Then I don't see any reason for him to lie about a result on Sean, whether he had been turned to mafia or not.

I think there haven't been Zombie kills because Sean has been jailing che. Sean is town jailkeeper turned cult, and che was town PI turned mafia.

I think the game obaf was referring to was bobs replicant game. That game was a * on the whole and an exception rather than the rule. If someone has been turned they'll know about it

 

Che was proven to be a cultist investigator and said you were cult and you had * all to say back to him other than just accusing him of being scum himself.

You would have been lynched by now, the only reason you weren't lynched was because you weren't seen as an immediate threat to town so we went for V and Aidan first.. who were both cult also.

Seems to be an awful lot of cult in this game though which is certainly strange.

We don't know if Che was converted or not .. killing you will allow us to know if Che had other motives

 

If Che was being jailed and mafia kills stopped then Mafia would have just sent someone else to do the killing, no?

 

Maybe they didn't have anyone else, or maybe they didn't know che was being jailed to prevent the kill, or maybe they didn't expect Sean to be able to jail che again (the lockdown made it possible to target the same person consecutively)

 

Che wasn't proven to be anything.

He offered up JC as Cult, which could very well have been a lucky stab in the dark or it could've been a cover play for him to get deeper in the game without scrutiny.

As @Dazza will very well know is a tactic, taking out Mafia Dayvig in the last game to give him credibility going forward.

It's funny how there was only 1 death in N3 and N5 when I had jailed Che, when we have Mafia and SK still in play...

 

Fair

Unvote Sean

The quiet ones Cena and Bagforlife have absolutely no reason to be assumed town as far as I'm aware?

Marie and Dazza I am reasonably confident are town.. Scotia too. In fact I'd be shocked if Scotia wasn't town but I've been shocked in these games before. You, unsure, but nobody else claims jailer and your story adds up considering there hasn't been two kills in a night by sk/mafia.

As has been said though, it would make no sense for Che to just pick JC as cult and hope he was right. Nonsense.. he knew JC was cult. After that is anyone's guess though because he may have been infected and pointed the finger at Sean to get a cheap kill for mafia. But doing so would have also meant he would be lynched the following day.

 

If he was bluffing and looking to coast through the game he would have offered up a not guilty result on someone the night after he got jc, far easier than claiming someone else is guilty. If we lynched you based on his result and you weren't cult, he would have been lynched immediately after

 

Wrongfully given, yes... Wrong, unlikely che would ask to be mod killed for that

 

Considering we have no info from last night whatsoever you can choose to lynch cookie or bag (not Cena) on a whim and you may well be right

Else you can lynch the one person we have an investigation on. Right now we should be 'following the cop' until he gets a wrong investigation

My vote won't be changing...

 

Forgot to address this point also in my reply.

I meant to say that I asked V to clarify why he was saying Moravcik was scum, while everyone else was just dive-bombing in and voting on him.

When I posted a 'Hmmm...' as I wondered if it was scum-led, I was asked why I wasn't voting on the info given up...when it hadn't been given. V then flipped cult.

Also I led the lynch on Aidan being cult, albeit I unvoted him for Che when he suggested we lynch him to prove I was Cult (bluff by him) so I was up for doing it, which would vindicate me. Once the consensus went with Aidan I did as I said earlier in the day phase and was happy to lynch either as they both read scummy to me. Which was then proven when he flipped cult.[/QUOTE]

 

How do you explain the lack of a Mafia/Sk kill most nights if Sean is not the jailer? Is it possible Sean was jailer originally and then converted to cult on the first night, while maintaining his role as jailer? I'm not ruling out lynching Sean, just rescinding my voter for the minute.

 

[/QUOTE]
Che wouldn't have 'read scummy' to you. That's the issue I have with you. You should have been singing from the roof tops to lynch Che because you would have been 100% sure he was lying. he wouldn't 'read scummy' he would be absolutely 100% nailed on scum.. yet you didn't say a thing and voted to lynch Aidan instead.