Transfer Talk

Good find, I just wonder if the competition he is playing against is good enough to justify signing him, as he looked to be walking around the other teams

 

Not sure if there is any truth in in whatsoever, but apparently we are going to be looking to sign Steven Naismith on loan in January. As I said, not sure if there is any truth in it, but something I got told yesterday.

 

would be a great signing if true

 

I wouldn't take Naismith here as a player. Not the type of style we're trying to build.

 

Really? I never saw much in Naismith at Killie, but he improved so much at Rangers and has continued getting better at Everton.

Hard-working, terrific attitude, can play in a couple of attacking positions and provides a goal threat.

I can't see him signing for us, though.

 

Can't pass the ball, can't beat a man, shocking first touch.

He's all effort and an exceptional ability to find space. For the wages I'd be expecting a * load more. I think the world cup qualifiers showed you someone like Shuan Maloney is a far more accomplished player.

 

I absolutely hate Naismith as a player. Forever rolling around, and just moans constantly. I think he is good enough to get in our team just now though. I'm just no sure I could stomach seeing him wearing the jersey.

 

He and Maloney have different skill sets for the positions they play. Maloney glides across the pitch while Naimsith charges around it. Maloney creates and Naismith gets on the end of things.

If we could afford both, I'd certainly take both.

 

That as well.

I think he'd hinder us, honestly donmy rate him at all. He can finish off moved but there is no creativity and no build up play in him. For the style we play it'd be frustrating as * to watch.

 

Using the qualifiers as an example and both there Scotland careers, Maloney tends to finish off more than Naismith as well. He's not a natural finisher for me, he has his games, likes his hat trick against Chelsea but he's not a good player for me.

Then add in his diving and that and it's just embarrasing.

 

I think Naismith would do a job here to be honest. Also adds an extra bit of experience as well.

 

What position does he play now ?

 

Rate Naismith and would probably end up liking him but he's a diving, cheating Hun *. If we're going for anyone on loan from Everton it has to be McGeady.

 

Nobody on loan. Permanent or * all. We can't be rebuilding again for the qualifiers.

 

True, it would have to be with an option to buy at the very least.

 

True, and even if it was permanent I wouldn't want him here. We've got enough workers in the team. We need some guile and technique, and this wee * doesn't have it.