So Who Stays?

No bother mate. It's a forum for opinions.

 

to true m8 lol , 1000th post happy days, ding dong, since feb to is that a record by any chance cause that seems pretty quick to me ? im for the pub CMON YOU REDS ( both of them ) lol

 

i would return all loans and sell if possible the following players:- Boruc, Hinkel,Naylor,McManus,Samaras,McGeady,Brown,Crosas,Mizuno,Zi,Fortune and Wilson.
We need two decent full backs and centre backs and obviously 2 strikers whom they are i dont know but i would deffo try get Lee Wallace as my left back the other positions i need to think over before giving names.:icon_mrgreen:

 

Scott Brown out if anyone pays 4 million plus .

 

the fact you go to most of the games no it doesnt mean u know what you are talking about. it means u are a fan who has an opiinon like the rest of us.
the current squad need a manager leader and a decent spine in the team. we have keepers but the rest of the spine needs sorted.

we have some good players and some who should be sold. We should try and get a strong leader of a manager like hodgson who ticks all the boxes and even he might be out of range but try anyway.

 

I hear Hodgsen being mentioned but I can't see it mate. I think he will want another crack at thr Premiership and try and keep Fulham in Europe, I'm just not sure on this manager thing

 

Stay on topic please, there is another thread for the next manager

 

I know mate, sorry

 

I would keep Boruc, Zaluska, Hinkel, Rogne, Hooiveld, McGeady, Maloney, Ki, ZZ, McCourt, Kamara, Crosas, Keane, Rasmussen.

The rest can go

 

first team for spl next season;

boruc
mcmanus rogne goncalves
crosas sidwell
duff brown kamara
rasmussen bellamy

ideal team for europe ;

boruc
hinkel hooiveld kjaer belhadj
bullard petrov ki kamara
bellamy carew

just a thought on next season losing alot of fringe players ;

mc geady , brown (sell both to highest bidder )
zheng zhi
samaras
naylor
mc court
fortune


that would be a good squad and clear out in an ideal world ,

 

Why Zhi

 

Dunno, just think theirs something there, any time I've seen him I liked the look of him, particularly at Ibrox early in the season.

 

i wish mate i really do

 

To be honest i would sell anyone if the right offer came in, the only question is if anyone wants to sign anyone and if their willing to pay good money instead of letting players away for buttons!

 

why do people have blinkers with McCourt.
he is clueless, greedy, paceless and injury prone

 

Yeah I suppose he is a player who we arn't seeing enough of and who hasn't had a real chance. He was really impressive at Ibrox come to think of it

 

out of the first team

boruc fortune crosas
hinkel brown rogne
mcgeady - to stay nguemo - can go thompson
kamara brafheeid mccourt - etc should all be given a
rassmusen mcginn chance as they havent
hooiveld featured much
samaras

 

Some players like Hooidveld, Rogne, Ki, Raasmussen deserve a chance as they have only come to the club under difficult circumstances and not had a real chance.

Others, like Fortune, McGeady, Hinkell, Crosas, Nguemo, McGinn, McCourt should be given a final " shape up or ship out warning. The rest, take what we get for them. Except for "Coco Pops" Broon...he gets a.." you're never gonna play for us again ya dud" rant

 

McGeady? Sometimes I wonder which Celtic games people are watching, because the ones that I watch, unless McGeady is ill or slightly injured and shouldn't be on the pitch anyhow, McGeady is usually the ONLY PERSON ON THE PITCH who is trying to make something happen, either for the strikers, or for himself. It is not his fault that usually when he puts an excellent ball in for Fortune or Kamara or whatever, their control and finishing is laughable. McGeady has been our only playmaker all season. If anyone MUST stay, its him. At least Darren O'Dea knew how to finish McGeady's ball in during the Well game. And Hinkel is the best Right Back this team has had since the MON era. These guys do not need to shape up. Its everyone else who does, with the exception of Boruc, who had a rough personal life this season, but still gave his 100%, and of course Keano.