McGeady - STAY OR GO

hinkel hasnt more assists than mcgeady

 

Still a decent return in a poor season for the team.

 

Fairynuff! But aiden should still be scoring about 15 a season and well more than 12 assists. His shOOting is pathetic and his crosses are worse.

 

i dont like him read my previous posts about him was just stating a fact

hinkel has 6 assists mcgeady has 11 still not enough

 

Mabye in a better team yes.

 

A better team won't improve his crossing and shOOting

 

He had two assists yesterday, if his team mates would put there chances away then he would have had 3-4.


All the people who have personal vendetta's against the bhoy can go hide under a log and moan about the colour of it for all I care, there will never be anything I can say to convince them because they will just wait to our next bad performance and start shouting there pish again. JOKE

And we will be having this same debate over and over and over until they finally get rid of him.

 

His shooting isn't the best I would admit, but every cross goes in the box.

We get a decent target man in the box, watch how his assist rate grows.

 

as i say i dont rate him because of his inconsistency but wish he played upto yesterdays standard all the time

if he stays i just want him to improve and be more consistently good

 

This is the strange thing, apart from the 2 assists, I thought he was poor for long spells yesterday.

 

he's alright , not the player people make him out to be .

I'd only sell him if a big offer came in though

 

Haha brilliant! Typical. Can't have an opinion about McGeady without being accused of having a personal agenda against him. Why is he shielded from critisism?

So before yesterday he had 10 assists! Waaaw! Genius!!

 

yeh that was my argument, he came through our ranks and he loves the club, and he is being repaid by the fans for his loyalty by people calling him * and wanting him to get lost when he doesnt play world class every game. pretty stupid if you ask me.

 

well thats not bad when a manger asks him to play differently and the team is playing shocking, and we are second, i always thought it was up to the strikers to score.

 

McGeady is having a rank poor season and if he stays he will need to take on board the coaching that is doubtless available to him. He's not the fast winger he thinks he is and most people know what his moves are so unless he gets some new ones he's gonna have a hard time. 10 million and he can go!

 

Keep McGeady- Lenny just needs to grab him by the bawsack and point him in the right direction!!

 

i think he looked more interested yesterday and had a wee bit more hunger

 

Agree, yesterday's performance was top class, that is what he is capable of

 

All the talk in here is that McGeady's 12 assists and 6 goals are not enough. Fair, I don't dispute he has the quality to offer more. But it is still more than anyone else in the side offers from a creative point of view. It may not be maximum output, but it is more than the rest of the midfield, do you see my point? If you let him go, you are getting rid of a player who, if at times frustrating, is also at times effective, moreso than any other player we have!

 

No one will offer 10m for him.

And as for him getting critisized for not being world class every week. Two points 1 he isn't world class 2 he'll be brilliant one week then * for about 4.

So what if he's a die hard tim that came through the ranks. Doesn't mean he should be treated any differently from anyone else.

He can't shoot or cross. He's been * for two seasons.