Mcgeady keep or sell, no comments needed

I cant believe what im seeing here, McGeady is a wonderfully talented player,Celtic have did this sort of thing all too often in the past with McClair and Dalglish.
He is our best player,We keep them and then we add to them..

 

sell!!

 

Sell, time is up at CP.

 

No keep him

 

Would be extremely foolish to sell him, as there's NO WAY we could persuade a player of similar quality to come and play in the SPL, even for twice the wage we're paying McGeady.

 

we have to sell him for the good of both parties, he is becoming stale in spl, and we need a player with drive and can finish, for £8mill + i could do without him, i want a player who can zip past full backs and send in quality crosses for strikers to attack,tricks dont impress when your getting beat in games against small teams

 

wel according to this poll mcgeadys like marmite lol u either like him or you dont

 

sell him

 

* would you even consider sellin McGeady for? no other player would fill his boots.... and what he has his hot and cold days on the pitch hasnt every other celtic player had their hot and cold days, when McGeady is on form he is top class and i have read many of posts where a lot of u * him and now he is in his "Cold" your all calling for him to get sold... i can see in the next few weeks he will be back on form and then all of you who have said yes you would sell him you will soon be makeing threads "oooooo Mcgeady your top class" a lot of you would of lick his * if you had the opportunity!

And some people sayin sell McGeady and get keane get a * life yea keane is a top class player and yea i would love to have keane at celtic park fulltime but people look at the age... whats the point splashing out on a massive transfer and massive wage just for a few years!

 

Sell.
It is time to go on.

 

mcgeady is having a bad season. but he is the only one that provides any creative spark, when he gets the ball in a bit of space, everyone in the stadium expects him to produce a bit of magic, everyone encourages him to take the defender on skin him rotten and that. cant be easy when every single defender in the country knows that all they have to do is half you. the whole of the creative responsibility of the team rests on his shoulders, i think if we had maloney or naka in the team then he would be performing much better, just needs someone to steal some of the defenders attention for a minute.

give him until january, guarantee he will win most of you over next year.

 

Can't cross
Can't shOOt
It's cheery bye from me and cheery bye from him

 

AYE time to move on

 

NOOOOOOO!!!!!!!

 

never in a million years hes by far our best player

 

I would definitely want to keep McGeady. He is one of our best players and when on his game can be really top quality. Certainly he has been inconsistent and at times average this season. But really that pretty much sums up this whole underperforming team this season so far.

 

another player in need of a good slap up the head, him and brown,
if aiden could sort out his attitude and maybe work on his finishing he'd be a great player

it all comes down to if he really wants to play for celtic, if he does, by next january, we'll know,