Mcgeady - Commons - Forest - Other

McGeady done it for 7 years..

Commons looks the part, a bit older than McGeady though and only time will tell. Nobody knew what to expect from him in the SPL, so we'll see how he does now.

People knew eventually how to play McGeady, for example, Kovacevic used to give him a good game when we played Dundee United.

Forrest will hopefully get better, but he's very young and it's unfair to compare him to these guys.

 

Commons has proved me wrong and been an amazing signing so far, so he wins hands down. We've been a much better side as I thought we would without McGeady in our first 11 every single * week. Just the same as before he became a first pick during the WGS days.

It's early days for Forrest but the main thing is we don't try to fit too many of these winger types into the one side anyway.