[Mafia] Mafia 37 - Deserted Island

When what I have said is proven correct town will kill you for The mafia dog you are.

Just to confirm - I am Jon Snow Watcher on the Wall.

Winter is coming for you Anton

 

If I had a scum role there is NO WAY I'd be giving up town JOAT

 

Is anyone going to counter claim the town watcher role ? If not there's no reason to doubt Che.

 

Plenty of reason to doubt Anton now though. 100% scum in my eyes

 

Well if you are, you may have said what you need to stay alive (adding a character claim does add weight).. however I find your confession without any real pressure very unlike you..

Like I said, on Day1 one of you three were always going to be lynched..

 

I reckon you've managed to push to the head of the queue

 

I wouldn't die anyway

 

.. the questions put and rationale are sound and I still think you could be lying..

 

Usually scum roles that are un-lynchable, is that what you’re claiming?

 

The role discards only give reasons to suspect. Two strong town roles are just as likely as anything else. They aren't proof positive by any means. Lynching by discarded alone is foolish.

What people post is far more instructive. Your posts tonight say much about your leanings. Scum I reckon- looking to take out a strong role by using discards as ammunition to save you a job at night

 

More to do with my character I believe.

 

There is still plenty of reason to doubt him..

 

Except there isnt

 

I’ve said nothing out the ordinary, it’s you who who has .. went on the offensive, role claiming under no pressure it’s not me who has the say..

I simply stated it should have been you or Pablo, I actually voted for Pablo initially as I deemed it the strongest discard.. you have sealed your own fate..

 

So you’re an unkillable Watcher? How many shots?

And you said you discarded a weaker role? Some role you’ve got, can you fly too?

 

I leave it to you @Beckenbauer , he’s full of *..

If I’m wrong feel free to get rid of me next..

I bid you goodnight..

 

@Beckenbauer before I go..

Ask yourself this, if @CheGuevara won't die if you pick him, why did he reveal his role? Makes zero sense..

 

Just caught up..

What are you saying here? First few posts telling Becks town will lose the Watcher if you are chosen, now saying you'll survive it?

From the discards I was thinking had to be scum in JC, Che, Pablo, Beck. Reassuring Che and JC are going at each other, makes me think one is right about the other, don't know which one, probs JC atm as Che's claim is a big one at least. Beck cant be lynched so ignoring that until next day phase. Pablo is hard to read atm.

 

Jon Snow comes back from the dead. When I picked my role I didn't know my character and wasn't told I would have a one shot unkillable. I think Keano added that in once I chose the role.

Everything I've said is true. Has anyone else claimed watcher? Has anyone counter claimed Jon Snow, one of the most iconic characters in TV History?

I had two very strong town roles and knew I would be targeted because of my discard, regardless. I discarded JOAT and tried to make it look like I had taken a slightly lesser role as I didn't want to draw attention and be targeted first night.

Scum will always target the big discards, because they know whoever gives them away, if they aren't in their faction, will have a big role left to play, either as town or a rival faction.

That's what we are seeing here. JC Anton is clearly scum, targeting myself and Pablo, to get rid of a big role without the need to do it at night, when we would both be targeted regardless. Figuring I would be a target at night, I thought it fairly reasonable to reveal my role early to let Beckenbauer make an informed decision.

Despite the full role and character reveal, uncontested as of yet, JC is still going full pelt at trying to get me lynched. It is clear to me he is scum.

 

You’re lying no doubt...

If I were scum I wouldn’t have engaged with you at all, your discard and indeed Pablos was always going to bring some heat..

There were three outstanding discards one at least will be scum, I have a Town role and this seems like a ploy to deflect and to get me to role claim at this early juncture..

You would have known you were one shot un-killable before you role claimed, no doubt.. which means there was no point in claiming such a big role as you would have been safe..

You are misdirecting and it’s a clear * up.. are you saying you didn’t know you were un-killable until after you claimed Watcher? That’s bullshit..

You took a punt with Watcher a role not always seen and then another punt with Jon Snow to make it work, you could have claimed both at the same time..

You lie...