Mafia 15 - Bhoy School Reunion

Problem we have here is anyone who has role claimed hasn't been counter claimed. Most if not all claims seem believable. To be fair its an unusual game, with so many reveals this early on.

The only thing we have to go on is Cenas claim that Boro is scum. If he gets lynched and turns out scum Cena has done town a favour. If not scum then Cena is for Lynching. This is the only way I can see us progressing on D2.
Im open to suggestions still but thats my thinking at present.

 

As discussed Cena (and importantly Efe) may be an insane cop.

 

There was only one kill last night for a start.

There is zero chance because a SK wouldn't win if he claimed miller.

Another faction, maybe. But we've gotten rid of the first 3rd party anyway, the brothers. Too early to guess if there are others.

Point is I can't be SK if I've claimed miller. It's stupid.
I also wouldn't have said I was happy to be lynched several times.

And if I wasn't town, I wouldn't have went for Dazza.

Still not convinced Cena is the insane cop.

 

It's not a lie. I'm Griffiths, the unlucky townie.

 

Imagine a game where we all voted for the person that the cop said was guilty! That would be brilliant.

Vote borobob

 

I'm ditching obaf's plan because I don't trust him. Being governed can just as easily be mafia and hopefully he's one shot.

We should vote for the person the cop has said is guilty. If Bob comes back as mafia we know Cena's insane cop/normal cop outcome.

I think obaf is manipulating the situation, so mafia can get rid of the cop tonight.

 

Personally think it's left field, but something that could work, as an SK or other faction.

This game is highly influenced by former games/reputation, and you're a reputable player. It makes you very likely to be investigated at some point, with the early Miller claim you have an instant defence, act alongside town and vote off mafia and your role as 'The Miller' becomes almost water tight.

Saying your happy to be lynched means zilch, I could say that, Dazza could of said that - Means nothing. Especially when you're nowhere near being lynched.

Che as SK, if In recall correctly, gave a great town performance while non-town. Was involved in loads of mafia kills and I'm sure even started some. You voting probably confirms your not mafia, but that's about it for me.

 

Re-read Che's latest post. I'm town.

Got to work now, but my vote is not changing now, made my decision.

If the cop says Bob is guilty then Bob has to go.

 

Can't believe you are still wasting your energy looking my way. I am town . You are being incredibly blinkered and one dimensional in your thinking , there's a huge possibility that Cena is playing you (he still hasn't answered my question on how my investigation was worded,scared of tripping himself up?)
, there's a huge possibility he is an insane cop.. you are willing to out another town player if this is true?

There is a plan that will show what cena is and you are doing your very best to * it up WHY?

 

But you claimed VT with that initial post, did you not?

So aye your green font matches up, but you don't even have a 'Vanilla town/townie' PM to look upon, so you've already proved you can make a half decent, educated assumption..

 

No-one has challenged him on being cop, so I believe he's a cop. I don't think he's an insane cop just because of the player he was given.

It's the single best bit of evidence we have so far.

I'm trying to find mafia. I don't trust obaf now so I don't give a * about his plan.

 

I didn't claim Vanilla Townie at any point. I said I was essentially a weakened VT because of how my investigation result would turn out.

Mine read as Unlucky Townie

 

Wait, but you're now 'The Miller'?

Is it the same thing, bit confused here...

 

Miller/Unlucky Townie are the exact same thing, just a different title. Give me a minute and I'll quote my opening posts. I've just been referring to the role by its most common name.

 

There is always the doubt that obaf is a mafia governor and that will mess up everything but the way I look at it is the plan was fairly in depth, the plan was almost off the cuff and it's the best plan we have.
I can appreciate that you want to follow the obvious evidence.. cop says guilty therefore guilty but I can promise you 2 things.

1. I am town.
2. If you do get the support to get me to L-1 I won't be lynched. Guaranteed

So put your efforts elsewhere. we have an 8pm deadline

 

Don't believe you.

 

If I am forced to reveal my role at L-1 I won't be lynched. Wether you believe me or not is irrelevant, you are one vote. I am just giving you advice, take it or leave it.

 

@ourdaywillcome!

These are two of my earliest posts in the thread.

I was fine with claiming Leigh Griffiths in my first post. Why? Because I'm being honest.

I was fine with being the first person to reveal my role. Why? Because it's a * role and because I'm being honest.

 

We already know you have a killing role.

 

Firstly I will be on most of today although my head is * thumping but I have a smile on my face about a mile wide ... 3 * nil it wasn't a dream

I was concise. Here is the question again -

Ps JC when i voted for you it was for valid reasons or do you deny that's how mafia play the game ? As for i voted for Town Doc well forgive me but you hadn't claimed that at that point had you ??
Now what was that you said about twisting things ... cause that's exactly what you have just done or tried to do anyway.

Seems pretty concise to me and only requires 2 Yes/No answers from you so why you are continually avoiding it makes me question why. The same way I am wary of Cena/Bob and now Minty as there is a plan in place, to help us, but for various reasons people are avoiding the question/action laid out, that bothers me also as the plan seems to be workable or have I missed something regarding OBAF not being trustworthy ?

To answer your question about the brothers I hadn't thought about brothers at all.