[Mafia] Mafia 11 - Mean Streets

When were you confirmed town Scotia

 

@Scotia Idioteque jailed me and a kill was still made, just like you. This just adds on to my reasoning with Dazza before - I am town.

 

idio jailed me the other night and a kill went through so couldn't have been me

 

guys I'm no up for this tonight sitting here for ages making an erse of my self , will check back in the morning .

 

@Cena have you nothing to say about OBAF vote on you ?

 

Cena had no choice but to kill Idioteque with me jailed. If he didn't, he's jailed next and no kill occurs and he's done for.

 

I'll lay it out

Scotia: Jailed and a kill occurred. Guaranteed town

Me: Jailed and a kill occurred, just like Scotia. Called out by someone with the power to block a mafia kill and he died when he most likely would have targeted me. One of the first 3 voters for the Mafia godfather kill. Sure I was absent early on but I had good reason, corroborated by how long it took to finish my Songquest. Guaranteed town.

Tim: I forget your argument but doesn't matter. See next.

Cena: Conveniently claims to be a role where he can't be killed at night, the role which the Mafia godfather this game was the only other one to have. Never voted for any mafia lynches. Has been absent with no excuse. No doubt the next jailer target and the jailer dies.

There's not much defense to be made IMO

 

Didn't even notice tbh but he's had a hardon for me recently so he can carry on imo it's between him and Scotia

 

Scotia is 100% Town.

Who says he didn't jail Cena last night ? I think he did jail Cena last night, see below for reason, Although he would have been better protecting himself because it was pretty obvious he would be targeted wasn't it ?

I trust you 100% and you are right to trust me.

Thing is I think idioteque jailed cena last night, based on the following post, as he says its between Cena and JC for him. Once he sees JC is innocent he would have jailed Cena. You even agreed with him, so why would he change his mind. -

Your reply -

So I see it like this -

Scotia we know is Town (Confirmed by Idioteque)
Cena claims Commuter (no one has challenged it and town having a 5th power roll matches the 5 mafia ,in total, we must be looking for AND he was probably the one who was jailed last night)
I am Vigilante (no-one has challenged this claim either, I took out Summer Time and have done nothing but try to get mafia from the start)

This leaves one odd one out so lets "launch" him ...

To quote someone "Hope your telescope gets rammed up your Brown Dwarf, Mafia Scum"

Its time we finished ramming the telescope up his Black Hole ..

Vote OBAF

 

Tim you've completely ignored that Idioteque only voted for Anton after I laid out a plan to catch the Mafia between the three of us. Your quote is cherry picked from before that. How you can vote me with the mountain of evidence stacked in my favor is beyond me. You're deluding yourself.

 

And that plan involved Idioteque jailing me. If that's not an implicit agreement I don't know what is. Also if he's truly the commuter how can he be jailed?

 

@Tim-Time 1888 How do you address as well that Cena calls out Scotia as potential mafia? In fact, the only person he doesn't think is mafia apparently is you - the person to whom he was replying with this comment. If this isn't an attempt to play you I don't know what is.

 

The reason for Idioteque vote -

No mention of him liking or agreeing with your plan although when it comes to agreeing and then following through on a plan, as we have already seen, that can easily be chucked out the window

How can anyone be jailed, they just can be, if a role exists that cant be jailed we haven't come across that so far in these games.

I'll admit that quote did/does bother me a bit, for exactly the reason you have gave. However on probabilities - he claimed a role not challenged, Idioteque probably jailed him and 5 power roles on each side, I have decided to pay less attention to it. If that was/is a bad call well done Cena he 'played' well although in future inactive players need to be mod killed earlier perhaps.

 

I'm leaving all this evidence here for you all to address because I'm finishing an observing run and so will be sleeping from 7am - 1pm today and will miss a lot

These were three consecutive posts at the end of the past night, with Idioteque ultimately making the final vote on Anton. This immediate succession, with JC removing his vote and saying my plan is good before Idioteque finishes the vote, makes it plainly obvious that Idioteque also agreed to my plan and therefore jailed me.

If you believe for whatever strange reason that Idioteque jailed Cena instead, I ask you - how could he be jailed as commuter? He can't be targeted if he leaves the town. Cena has only cryptically said he can commute out "sometimes." He's been absent all game and has given no specifics on his role other than claiming it, and that role has only been used in one other game by, guess who, THE MAFIA GODFATHER. @Tim-Time 1888 you say you believe him just because he role claimed and nobody called against? I have so much more evidence in my favor than that. And he says Scotia is likely mafia when we all agreed Scotia is guaranteed town - he very clearly wants to get rid of us.

Read this post for the rest of my argument:

You are evidently not voting with logic right now @Tim-Time 1888 and you're going to lose this for us. Look at the facts.

 

You keep talking about probabilities but you aren't actually paying attention to what is most probable. Idioteque only voted for Anton after Anton agreed to my plan. There is nothing indicated he would have gone for Cena.

 

I'm going to bed as I've been awake for almost 24 hours. In the meantime, I urge you to please look at actual things that happened in this game and decide based on evidence rather than "he said this" and speculation based on how you think things should be. I've given a very strong argument for myself and Cena has none.

BE VERY CAREFUL

 

If that's right then he should have said who he planned on jailing, as it is I can only go on what he has said and that was he suspected Cena and JC. As JC is gone then surely he would have jailed his stated suspect next, who was Cena.
If he changed that he would have said so, as would anyone at that point knowing there was a chance they wouldn't see the night out.

 

right had a read .... vote oba

 

The way you two can laugh in the face of reason is beyond me

@Tim-Time 1888 @Scotia what is the evidence that you think makes it more likely that Idioteque jailed Cena than me?

 

@Tim-Time 1888 you quote this post as evidence that Idioteque thinks it's Cena

Do you really not see that this is a reply to me asking me who I think is mafia???

Would Idioteque say "Hey obaf, do you think obaf is mafia?"

Honestly have a * look at context Jesus Christ