[Mafia] Lord of the Greatest Idea Mafia - Orcs win

If I was mafia don't you think I would of jumped straight onto voting for Obaf, when voting for Doc it was only when Keano quoted a post that looked like a * up by Doc saying he had a mafia role but he just made a mistake in the wording.

 

I swear I'm no scum. I'm a good Papist boy.

 

That is straight out of the Aiden O’Shay textbook. A real shady move, buddy.

 

...* wrong cartoon

 

When I read the article the first time I didn't click on the judas part. I see what you mean now. I still cant work out why OBAF would pick a role like either of them tbh surely to * out of 3 cards you can make a better role than one of these.
Am thinking he is what Che was in a previous game (goo) and seen that Che stayed silent or could Che's role only be killed by lynch or was it vice a versa ? I forget now these games/roles are starting to merge into one tbh.

I know what your saying but from my time playing mafia we would prefer in the early lynches to avoid voting or just one of us, both Keano and Idio are WW so that was risky for them. I still think those who didn't vote - V, Cena and Deebo need to be looked at and say more tbh.

The eagerness to lynch OBAF, from some, is interesting. I am unsure if we should or shouldn't lynch him although he cant stay til the end, if it goes that far.

I wont be voting tonight as I want to hear from others. I would also like to hear what others think is left - WW, Alien, SK and mafia although I thought they maybe aren't a faction in this game, maybe that was wrong of me though as eddie pointed out.

 

Yeah that's what I was thinking as well, maybe he picked it to * around, he discarded Vanilla Townie so his other 2 options might of been * and just wanted something different.
I don't see him as a direct threat just now anyway, leave him to go mad with the gifs just now.

And exactly, we need more time to try and figure out the others and see what they say over the next day or so, I'm always wary of the folk that pop in and out now and again not trying to help figure * out, they try and stay neutral which points more to anti-town.

 

2 Werewolves have died already, yeah? Are there likely to be any left, do you reckon?

 

Well JC was mauled so there must be 1 left? Unless WW carry out their attacks no matter if they are killed that night?

 

What do you think of tims point about v, cena and Deebo. Any of them suspicious to you?

All of the night actions happen at the same time so yes the wolf attack would still happen even though 2 wolves die

I think there's probably the most Mafia, 1 or 0 wolves left, and maybe just 1 alien. Aliens are only allowed one night kill per game, so I don't think many would have chose them. Probably 1 or 2 serial killers also. From what I can gather greatest Mafia games are always quick because there's so many scum. But it's all guess work.

 

Yeah all 3 given their few posts so far and not contributing much, well V has a little so would say he is less suspicious than Cena and Deebo. Eddie has been quick to vote Obaf and was first to vote for Doc but given behavior of both it's hard to judge if he's town or looking to try and get quick lynches in.

Okay that clears that up for me then cheers.

Aye the fact no serial killers were discarded is quite worrying so definitely at least 1, not actually sure on the mafia how many there are, at least there can't be a godfather though.

As Tim said we should wait for others to chip in a bit and see what they say, there's no rush for voting with the deadline being Friday.

 

There's also a chance of a godfather as there's a "town godfather" role, so someone might have combined that with Mafia

 

I'll back a lynch on V

Cookie and v are in cohoots imo

 

Ive caught up with a fair bit of thread now.

Without looking too much into discards or any of that stuff (I'll just confuse myself even more) then I am leaning towards thinking both Scotia and Tim are town. I think one of Cookie and Dazza are town, but one of them is likely a bad egg and perhaps a serial killer (I presume we have one going by the amount of deaths we had and the use of a machete).

People that are reading as most suspicious to me are Aidan and Eddie. Aidan for the post I already quoted and Eddie because I thought his reasoning for wanting to lynch Obaf was a bit weak. Mafia players tend to jump on an easy lynch which is what Obaf has made himself.

 

Never knew that, ahh * sake too many roles in this game.

In Cahoots with V? What are you on about now? I really can't keep track of your thought process.

 

Lynch v
Doctor save/jail me
Lynch cookie

Or in reverse

Would be lovely for town

 

Are you taking the dipper? There are people posting far less than me, you accuse cookie of latching into the Obaf lynch as an easy vote but you've just latched on us because someone's brought it up. Tim, again your talking Pish, Iv not posted loss, but sit here and tell me what you want me to be posting? There's * all to go on, just because I don't post random push and and get my post count up on here doesn't mean I'm contributing any less, youse are just waffling on about *, it's easy to point finger at people who are not posting loads as an easy way out.

Iv voted Obaf, what the * is he contributing posting gifs?

 

I think Dazza has overplayed his hand, quite an aggressive approach at me to get lynched while not taking notice of others. You've also asked a few times about voting ideas saying you would change your vote which is strange to me.

 

Based on what, because I'm not posting random *