Keane V Boyd

Were on a celtic forum lol. Keane is better though. Even if someone was of the opinion Boyd was they would still say Keane. Boyds Pish

 

There is no denyin that boyd is an ugly fat hun and would never let him near a celtic jersey.

puttin this aside if it was just on ability keane is going to score more goals outside domestic competitions however within scotland i would have to say boyd. proves it every year in a pish rangers side. would only get more chances with us.

facts prove he is * against the big teams but if he plays in a team who is constantly looking to create chances and dont just sit on a 1-0 lead would he become a better player and get more chances and goals?

 

Slightly off topic but been thinking about Keane. If he was to score winning goal this Sunday then sales of Keano merchandise will fly off the shelves, and he will become an instant hero to us fans, more so than say big Ras due to the irish connection. At end of season he goes back down south where he isnt guaranteed first team football or Europe every year. Should he stay up here, he is an instant hero which is good for his ego and becomes a big fish in a small pond compared to being a small fish in a big pond down south, he is guaranteed first team football and as good as guaranteed European football every season without fail with us. The only sticking point could be his obvious wage demands, and maybe concerns re the lower standard of opposition he would be pitched against up here as opposed to the EPL. Im starting to believe that he could be here longer than the end of this season, especially if he wins the game for us on Sunday.

 

Kenny Dalglish?!?!

This is a tough one. I think in terms of quality, Keane gets the nod, but in terms of pure scoring it has to go to Boyd.

Give me Keane in all seasons, except this one. Boyd's goals would have done us good this year.