IS KEANE IN THE SAME BRACKET AS LARSSON AND JINKY

the point people are missing here is its the spl.he cant be overated cause there is no player to compare him with
in this * league. hes a breath of fresh air
on an otherwise dull weekend

 

Looking back at the 1.5 Games Keane has played for Celtic.. and take account the chances he has missed.. Do you think Larsson or Jinky would have missed those chances? Mainly Larsson im askin the question of since iv seen full games of Larsson and only clips of Jinky. Im not saying Larsson put away 100% of his chances, but out of 1.5 games Keane's goal was a penalty and all of a sudden hes the "goal scoring machine" were as Do you think Henrik would have finnished those chances?

 

again i quote ask me in seven years
if robbie stayed that time.although
it pains me to say it henrik missed
some important penalties in his time

 

It's a stupid poll, why stop at the three players mentioned why not include, Bobby Lennox, Stevie Chalmers, Joe McBride etc etc.
A comparison can only be made when you have witnessed all three of them over a sustained period, as I have.
For goal scoring it has to be Joe McBride, for overall skill and entertainment no one will ever compare to Jinky, it saddens me to say that we will never see the likes of him again.

 

I will quote, because i won't be able to ask you about Keane in 7 years because he won't even be here for 7 months.

 

Jinky for sure.

I voted Larsson as he's a legend of my time, someone I watched for every home game he played for us, so he'll always be my choice when it comes to these.

Keane, if he stays, MIGHT get in to a similar bracket, but if he does intend on going back to spurs and that being the end of it, he'll never hit those heights of legendary status with us.

 

I don't think he's anywhere near these guys in terms of ability. Of course he will never stay and reach the consistency or win the silverware that the other 2 have. So it's not really a fair matchup.

Keane is a very good player but even if he signed long term tomorrow, I don't think he could become a great.

 

Lets hope so, but its early days

 

Keane

as he is only here 6 months he would have to score a hat trick every game to be considered in larsson or jinkys class.

 

no

 

I think this is on wrong thread.there is one in pub talk asking for your
controversial opinions:icon_mrgreen:

 

ITS NOT THE SAME MATE IF SO WHY ARE SO MANY PEOPLE POSTING

 

Sorry mate just looked at what you meant

 

How Can u even add Keane in the same Vote as Larsson and Jinky ?

 

No and never

 

This

 

I told yous so, he is the MAN

 

looks like the sort of goal henrik would score. :icon_mrgreen:

 

Keane is more prolific

 

(No.)