'Honest' mistakes 24/25

I think the whole game is rotten to the core, in Scotland, in England, in the CL.

 

Thought WC could handed them a few yellow cards early days but ultimately he had a decent game.

 

He showed why he's the best rated ref we have in Scotland. Only one with balls to stand by his own decision.

 

Collum was OK overall even though he bought the sevco players dying Swan routines more than once. About as good as we can expect atm though. Good on him for sticking to his pen decision, a lot of refs feel duty-bound to go along with VAR when called over. McLean on the other hand.....

 

Had a good game overall I thought, that Diomande should have received a yellow card like, got away with foul after foul. The * on VAR were at it like

 

Aye collum was fine today, only gripe is Diomamde not getting carded.

Fair play for sticking to his decision.

 

See what happens when an impartial ref is appointed for these games.

Collum may not be the best, but he had a decent game today. Should've booked a few huns, u other than that he was doing his job.

 

Aye he was surprisingly decent

 

Shows how bad things are that we praise that performance if he followed the rules they would be down to 9, to think how bad it would have been if it was one of the dirty dozen as ref

Sent from my 21121210G using Tapatalk

 

Nice Little slow down by McLean today when the penalty was given.....*

 

He'll never ref the derby again after that..

Sticking to his original, correct decision. Mental that was reviewed considering the contact where O'Riley was about to let a shot off and how it wasn't a clear and obvious mistake. Shameless beyond belief from that dob McLean..

That * Miller tortured his self today but it was clear to me the narrative he was trying to spin when Collum was shouting I'm the referee at Diomande first half. Was saying why does he need to be so aggressive to the players but what he really was trying to say is why is he shouting and screaming at hun players..

 

Im surprised that the Sterling hand ball 1 hasn't had that much attention, yeah his hands are at his side but he motions towards the ball, the kind of penalties you know who get all the time

 

It was a stonewall penalty. I think everyone was baffled that it took so long to look at and then a review was requested.

That was highly concerning, but Collum did the right thing. VAR again put itself in the spotlight needlessly.

 

Collum is one of the worst referees I've ever seen; but he's never been biased. I loved how VAR called him over to look at that penalty and he walked over, looked at it and decided it was still a penalty. Fair play to him for that.

 

He may well have reffed himself into contention for the Euros after that... Can't imagine that the UEFA overseers will report back anything other than that he did a good job, showed some stones when required and pretty much did a completely professional job in a massively stressful game...

He's * in Scotland though... The Huns will pariah him even more than usual, I'd imagine

 

All huns and pundits moaning about the penalty, are the same people that would be 100% screaming for it to be given if it was the other way.

The fact VAR even sent Collum to the monitor is laughable. Huns would be getting it given without the need for a review. And they've had pens given for far less this season.

 

I would rather Column ref, always said he is fair but he can just be incompetent and make howling calls at times, VAR sort of balances that out a bit.

 

I knew at the game it was a stonewall penalty. You could see O’Riley getting tripped. Couldn’t believe when he was asked to go over to the screen. Fair play to him for sticking with the correct decision. Red card was bang on as well. He got the big calls right.