[Mafia] Greatest Idea Mafia - Day 5

I’m torn between you and Deebo.

 

Aye, that seems wise, Aidan. Eddie seems to be telling the truth about his role (not alignment). There’s not much a scum-aligned Cop can learn at Thisbe point of the game now anyway, if Deebo is telling the truth about his role (not alignment).

 

Unvote Eddie

Need to take a breath here and look at these claims and counter claims..

 

but have i claimed cop ?

No, if vert is cop and you are innocent lynching philly and proving that is your main goal.

But i'm the one that outed a liar so i get the votes. dumb move .

 

So much going g on here in the last 20 mins hard to take it all in

 

If aidan and vert are town then surely lynching Deebo would prove that, except they vote me

because they hoped to get the lynch done fast as JC already had a vote on me.

 

So you think Deebo is town cop and they are scum alinnged ?

 

Sorry explain that mate.

 

No. You’re the one who can block my investigation into one of Cookie and Idioteque (because you and Deebo are almost certainly linked, in my mind). Deebo, if my suspicions are correct, knows that Aidan, JC and I are Town - the only thing that he can learn then is whether Cookie or Idioteque are Town or in another faction, if one or both are not in yours (I’m not sure of the maths).

If Deebo is Town, he, you, Aidan and I are Town (and perhaps an other or others), but I find that highly unlikely.

 

if Deebo is lying about being cop then it proves Vert is telling the truth

as soon as i voted vert Aidan jumped to vote me and then told vert to vote aswell.

what would lynching me prove ?

nothing, they can't lynch pgilly because it proves vert to be a liar.

 

As I’ve said, I’m happy to be a martyr, if the Town thinks it an survive the night. Once my role’s confirmed, my suspicions most likely are too.

 

If Aidan and I were in cahoots, do you not think that I would have changed my vote on Deebo first to avoid that suspicion?

 

Why would Deebo claim Cop, when there’s been so many tho?

 

The fact that Eddie is completely unquestioning of Deebo, despite someone (I can’t remember who) raising the possibility of my being scum and trying to win the trust of Aidan, should set alarm bells ringing.

I’m going to check whether or not it was him actually.

 

It was Deebo.

I’ll throw that back at him.

Why haven’t you questioned whether or not Deebo is simply trying to win your trust, if you are Town, Eddie?

 

So much misdirecting going on here, I’m going to keep it simple as I can over think it at times..

Sorry if wrong Ed.. but going with my original feeling that you * up..

Think you are an anti-Town Roleblocker.. if I’m wrong your death won’t be in vain..

Vote Eddie

 

Maybe because he is cop ? I was siding with vert until he started to argue against the fact he can only investigate mafia.

You know how this game works, cop investigates mafia.

 

JC has to be mafia too, only explanation he isn’t dumb enough to side with that obvious bulls hit

 

@CookieMonster @Idioteque @JC Anton

Why, after it was made clear that there was a kill, did he come out with this?

Particularly, after I had confirmed Aidan was ‘good’.

See JC’s initial suspicions as well.

 

Because he never called you a liar

You are claiming you can investigate all factions COP CANT

lynching Deebo proves you or him is right, lynching me proves nothing

Vert, Aidan and JC are scum