Death Penalty Yes or No??

Nothing wrong with my attitude

Go back a good few posts,I said the crime should fit the punishment
Your explanation is an all different ball game

I have been talking about the most sickly criminals that are out there

There is * all flawed about my feelings especially when you have had
Close friends butchered

And the doctor ffs he will be doing his job

 

At which point have I said I don't?

The doctor will be doing his job? Is that so. So you'd have no problem seeing a hired assassin walk free of the death penalty then? Doubt it somehow.

See my above post, I meant to add it to the last one.

 

I doctor must take part in it if was to be in any way humane..
Leathal Injection, im not sure but i assume a doctor would be the only person who could perform this, at least someone who has knowledge in it..

 

I never expected that there would be so many people on here that actually gave a * about what happened to murderers,rapists etc. More people seem concerned about the rights of them than about the people who have had their lives taken away or were raped .

 

Debatable ffs your a comedian now :bbpd:

So now the doctor who is carrying out a job by the state ,is an assissin

Stop watching those daft movies kidda

 

Exactly

 

I would agree with that part, like it or not if the state deem someone to be the excutioner he is immune to proscution for that excution.

 

Would that not be a violation of their hippocratic oath?

 

Che killed a grand total of 8 people, 5 in a setting of war and three who were guilty of rape and murder in the field. After the war was over an estimated 240 war criminals from Batista's regime were tried and executed, where Che was the final arbiter.

This all took place in a different time and in a very different setting. Batista's men had killed 20,000 Cubans in a year before the revolution was completed. There was a lot of anger amonsgst the general populace to the people who had been guilty of aiding and abetting the "disappearances".

I can completely understand Che's own actions, and I can understand the anger of the people. I personally would have liked the process to have been more formal, but I don't think that there would have been any other way in 1950's Cuba, than what took place.

 

Like you see in the movies mate?

 

No. Like I saw in Pentonville.

 

Im not sure what way thats works actually...
I supose if its a state sanctioned killing its legal maybe??

 

Zat not what vets take?

 

no, too many mistakes, plus death is relieving them of all suffering, let them rot in jail with their conscience

 

I can't see why you've bolded that part of my post with that first response tbh. Doesn't seem to make sense.

Anyway - explain the difference. One is being paid to kill someone, the other is also ostensibly being paid to kill someone. The only difference is one is state-sponsored. Does that make it right? To you it obviously does, but not to me.

You've already proved the kind of blasé, tabloid, attitude you have towards capital punishment by not giving two * no matter how many innocent lives would be lost were it implemented; so perhaps there is no point in debating this with you. That precise point of your argument I have a problem with is lost on you, as is the irony of being in favour of the death penalty "in certain situations" but not caring should innocent people die in the process.

 

No they can't. Doctors have never been involved with the execution of prisoners. Their attendance at some is to confirm that the prisoner is indeed dead.

 

But is that still not technically state sanctioned murder which you completly oppose in this country??
Might be a different time we live in but excution is still legal in Cuba today..

 

Good point there,you can't really call them assassins thou there is no under the radar killings here,it's all done above board and if its like the US maybe a public gallery

 

I am quite sure that no matter the circumstances - even political - doctors who take the oath must take every measure possible to preserve life.

 

BAsically what I think too. Innocents would get executed.