Daily Record Player Ratings?

Sky Sports | Football News | Player Ratings | Celtic v St Mirren - 22nd August 2010

Proper ratings.

 

Celtic 4-0 St Mirren

SCORING SUMMARY

Celtic /St Mirren
Joe Ledley (5)
Shaun Maloney (23)
James Forrest (69)
Ki Sung-Yueng (81)

MATCH STATS

Celtic / St Mirren

Shots (on Goal) 16(8) 1(1)
Fouls 7 6
Corner Kicks 12 0
Offsides 1 5
Time of Possession 66% 34%
Yellow Cards 1 2
Red Cards 0 0
Saves 2 6
MATCH INFORMATION
Stadium: Celtic Park, Scotland
Attendance: 46,812
Match Time: 10:00 ET
Official(s):
E Norris (Referee)

Having watched the game and seen the stats it clearly shows one team was in command from start to finish. I therefore think its fair to say the defence had very little to do and the ratings applied to them are fair.

 

He didn't score more than Kayal....who was the STAR MAN. The comments against each player are fair imo

 

based on fans opinion, yes.

 

Well would you like to take the view of the fan's or the Daily Rangers?

 

I take my own view. Always do.

 

Your always right aren't you:icon_mrgreen:

 

Nope and i haven't suggested that either. Get involved in the discussion rather than trying to have a go at a poster.

 

Mark Brown got a 6 for 4 letting in 3 goals yesterday, Paul Gallagher gets an 8 for letting in 4??? Crazy

 

Surely its about the performance as a whole in goal rather than the goals conceded. Say the goalkeeper was at fault for the goals for exampke you would expect a difference or if one kept the score to 4 rather than 6 or 6 or whatever.

 

Mark Brown also had a few decent saves to keep the score down. The only real save i remember Gallagher making was the Samaras shot, the rest went wide or hit the crossbar or it post.

 

Brown came out flapping many times in the 30 mins i seen.

I know its all about opinions but i think the goals conceded by a keepr can be irrelevant in some cases.

 

why the * are we arguing about this

 

Ok i agree with the second sentence there wasnt much he could do for James or ki's goals but i believe he was suspect for both Ledleys and Maloneys goals

 

I've stopped reading the record and other red tops. If you don't like their comments then quite simply don't buy or click. On a side note can't wait fir the Larsson interview at the end of week. Celtic reporting the type I like!

 

To be fair the only rating im angry about is the Darren McGregor one, 7? A * 7? What exactly did he do that he supposedly had a better game than Juarez (who got forward and controlled the game for long periods) and Brown (Who IMO was absolutely superb from start to finish).. That rating is an absolute joke, the lad did * all, all game.

 

how can you rate the celtic defence or goalkeeper any higher than 6? they done f'all. infact Zaluska saved 1 shot , and got a 6. he nearly caused goals with his pish decision making.

 

Personally I think Juarez was outstanding again and deserved more than a 6.

 

If St Mirren had beaten us 4-0 the majority of there players would be 8 and 9 . Wouldn't read to much into it though let them right us off at there pearl .