Would you sign skippy back?? [Threads Merged]

would you sign scott mcdonald back for 3.5 mil strachan wanted for him? (correct me if im wrong)

i personaly would get rid of sami and get mcdonald

 

we dont need to punt any strikers
sammy is the best of the lot of them
but yes i'd take skippy back

 

nope especially for 3.5million. not that I didn't appreciate everything he done coz I do. I just think that we need to move on from our ex players like skippy & co.

 

Shouldn't have got rid of him in the first place. * TM

 

i understand what some of yous are say but he would be our first choice striker if mowbray didnt get rid of him. who says he wouldnt have scored as much goals as keane?

and keane did score a few pens

 

got to look forward, not back, and I think we can do better for that kind of money.

 

Moanin' faced, greetin' wee gimp.

Crackin' player but there are better forwards out there.

 

Not worth £3.5 million in my opinion but would take him back if the price was lower. £2m maybe

 

Nope. Never go back.

He was good while he was here but we got decent monry for him.
Think 1 of the main resons he was sold was he was the "mole" that went to the press around the time of the Arsenal game and told them tactics, formation, starting line up all cause he wasn't starting.

 

Have him back in a flash, moaning wee * but we need a goal scorer and someone we know will do a job.

Dnt know what Lenny's opinion of him is right enough

 

agreed i think the 3mil or whatever we got for him was a decent price . I would be disappointed if the transfer window closes and we haven't signed a class striker with the money hopefully raised by the sale of mcgeady

 

He should never have been sold in the first place IMO, id have him back, much better than anything we currently have thats for sure.

 

No his attitude and form were poor last 6 months under wgs and half a season under btm got good price for him wouldnt bring him back especially for that price got a couple of good seasons out of him and made a good profit job done no return

 

could anyone name a striker we would get for his price , tht does just as good a job???? maybe stokes but hes a wee *

 

I would have Skippy back for sure

 

why is he a 'wee *"

 

No chance was a waste of a jersey in his last 12 months also Lennon revealing he was the mole in the dressing room he won't be back

 

firmly believe this as well. he's a rat and can walk alone for all i care. thanks for all ye did but that's inexcusable.

 

Same here, if he was the mole he doesn't deserve to wear the hoops.

Even on footballing terms I wouldn't take him back, after he got his contract extension and improved deal his form went right out the window.