Celtic Right Back

I know this has been done millions of times, but i am curious to see how a poll would finish...

i voted cadis showed early in the season he can defend, good going forward and is quick

 

The Germanator gets my vote.

 

I'm gonna go with Caddis also, cos i'd like to see him given a chance to prove himself as i feel that at Celtic we don't really give our kids much of a shot with the recent exception of Sheridan

 

agree mate, i think that when caddis has came on he has been great dont see why he shouldnt get a go try get himself in the team for the huns game

 

Hinkel's been fantastic, we haven't seen enough of Caddis this season to judge.

 

Hinkel. Caddis could well turn into a great right back but at this stage i think he'd be better off with the burden of having to be a defender first and foremost, his attacking play is far too useful for that.

 

hinkel obviously.. he's only had 1 off day so far (hearts) and not wilson (he's our LB atm) but i do rate caddis... and he'll get his turn when destiny strikes hinkel (injury)

 

As much as i'd like to see Caddis getting in the team, i'd go for Hinkel right now He's been improving and is starting to come on to a game.

 

Hinkel on recent form always for Caddis getting a game though great wee player for us.

 

Hinkel has been much better this season and does not deserve to be droped.

 

im not meaning on form, i mean a personal opinion...start of season who would your right back be for the first game

for me caddis he just seems to have more life about him than hinkel

 

hinkel. caddis is better as a winger

 

Without doubt Hinkel is 1st choice. Caddis is too slight and small for RB

 

too small ?

thats garbage you dont need to be tall to be a right or left back !

tosh mckinley was small....mcnamara wasnt the tallest and neither is wilson !

dont agree with that one mate, but at the end of the day its all about opinion

 

They were strong for their size, Caddis is slight as stated earlier

 

fair point but still i disagree i believe caddis could more than hold his own at the top level of football

 

Would you drop Hinkel for him?

 

i would certainly give him a chance at some point in the NEAR future

ideal oppourtunity on sunday against falkirk

 

Hinkel without a doubt the lad has sorted himself out and began to play like he should.And Mark Wilson,s arm,s are too big

 

Think this could be another case of "they are young and promising" so haaaaaave to start games.

Strachan has been quoted as saying we will be seeing a lot more of Caddis in the future and with the pressure on each SPL game from now on we have to go with experience rather than an unknown quantity...