Having trouble logging in by clicking the link at the top right of the page? Click here to be taken to the log in page.
Dismiss Notice

The board

Discussion in 'Celtic Chat' started by Cumbernauld Bhoy67, Nov 29, 2023.

Discuss The board in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.

Page 46 of 47

The Crow Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Oct 6, 2012

Messages:

177,084

Likes Received:

104,910

Found the full interview with the old man

The Crow said: ↑

Softly-spoken, sometimes smiling and sometimes serious, Dermot Desmond’s conversation ranges from him selling programmes as a boy in Dublin in the 1950s to Celtic’s match last Saturday at Ross County. He speaks of seeing Atletico Madrid in 1958 and Celtic’s League Cup final win over Rangers last December. In between, there are mentions for Guus Hiddink, Alex Ferguson and Mr Micawber, as well as 21st century Celtic figures such as Martin O’Neill, Henrik Larsson, Brendan Rodgers and Neil Lennon. Most of all, there is the here and now.

Desmond, 70, has been Celtic’s principal shareholder for more than two decades. He is an Irish businessman of expansive wealth and prudent practice. The latter sees him quoting Charles Dickens, and Desmond’s economic worldview is unlikely to be relaxed by a global pandemic.

Asked to assess the state of Scottish football in September 2020 in three words, Desmond replies with: “Experimental. Fearful. Devastating.” His tone, however, is not nervous. Panic is a non-strategy he has long tried to avoid.

“Experimental, I’d say — like all other leagues without fans,” Desmond begins. “Fearful – for all the clubs. They don’t know what the financial consequences will be. Without the ancillary income from fans attending, stadium income, that has an adverse effect, especially in Scotland because there is no major TV royalties. And third, I’d say devastating – for national organisations that run the various leagues etc, the SFA, the SPFL. It’s a really tough time.”

And before the pandemic?

Desmond speaks publicly rarely, but in the past he has been vocal on the finances of Scottish football, where one or the other of the two Glasgow giants have been champions every season since 1985. He has also pushed for Celtic and Rangers to join English and Welsh clubs to create a British Premier League.

“In Scotland, the reality is you’ve got two behemoths in Rangers and Celtic and they’ve got budgets because of their support base that outstrip all the other competition,” he says. “And there’s no way of equalising that, you can’t equalise it. So, therefore, you have this rivalry between Celtic and Rangers.

“It’s the financial situation. Look at all the countries in Europe now who can attract players and pay them as well if not better than Scottish clubs, that’s just the economic reality. I’ve got huge admiration for Scottish clubs and how they survive, how ingenious and creative they are at balancing their budgets, they’ve produced some great footballers and when you’ve got limited budgets in a competitive landscape, it’s very hard to compete with the budgets of Celtic and Rangers. Pound for pound, some of them outperform the budgets of Celtic and Rangers, no doubt about that.”

It has been some time since the concept of Celtic and Rangers playing in England has been mooted seriously and in 2020 Desmond is not in campaign mode. Realistically, is that idea over?

“I don’t know if it’s over,” he says. “Everything now is about the size of clubs and their followings. It’s become a digital world – streaming, Zoom. This pandemic has changed things.

“Now, what are we going to see with football? Will we see clubs sell their own international rights, take more control of their finances internationally? If that’s the case, because you know the top clubs in England want to control their international rights, those rights will be far more valuable if they’re playing against Celtic and Rangers.

“Celtic and Rangers are in the top eight clubs in Great Britain by any metric – support, attendance, international appeal. At some stage, there’s going to be the realisation that if they want to maximise their revenues, then there’ll be a British Premier League. And there should be a British Premier League, because you already have a couple of Welsh teams in the English leagues. So why not?

“As we get more digitally advanced and as clubs take more control of their revenue streams — particularly broadcasting revenues — that will create more potential for Celtic and Rangers, and maybe some other Scottish clubs, to be invited into British leagues.”

Is this a conversation he is having with relevant parties?

“I’m having no conversations, no. I had all the conversations throughout the years – turkeys aren’t going to vote for Christmas. But digital forces will, I think, make English clubs reconsider the construction of their leagues.”

So the status quo endures. Celtic are Scottish champions and have been for the past nine seasons. Make it 10 and they will have set a record. Ten in a row may not excite many outside the Glasgow bubble, but from within, it is top of the domestic agenda.

When Scottish clubs lose in Europe, though, as Celtic did to Ferencvaros last month in a Champions League qualifier, there is, even within Glasgow, distress at the external reputational damage. Desmond is calm even when returning to that disappointment, although he does sound slightly exasperated when asked whether he is motivated more by Europe or 10 in a row.

“Every year since I have had somewhat of an influence within the club, the ambition is to improve in every metric, full stop,” he says. “We want to win the league, the cups, succeed in Europe. We want to entertain better, we want the club to carry out its functions in a highly professional way in every single department. That’s the strategy and ambition of the board.

“So whether it’s 10 in a row or six in a row or two in a row, what we want to do is to improve. We want to improve our methodology in every operating department.

“If, in 2000, you’d said Celtic will have won 15 leagues and 20-odd trophies and we’ve had the ‘Invincibles’ and the Treble and you say to the fans, ‘Is that enough?’ Their reply would definitely be no.

“It’s never enough, and 10 in a row won’t be enough. So these are all mythical things to me. It’s nice. It’s nice to set a record, but the ambition is to perform to your utmost and, at the end of the season, give yourself a mark.

“You can win a league or win a cup and you say to yourself, ‘Yes, it’s great.’ But we won the League Cup last year and Rangers played better than us in the final – it’s gone the other way plenty of times, by the way. So it was a bit bittersweet in the sense we stole it.

“What we had to look at was why we underperformed and it was the same when they beat us at Celtic Park. How did that happen and what can we learn from it at all levels: the players, management, the board? That’s what’s so good at Celtic, we’re unified, we don’t have recriminations, we’re not here to fire somebody or blame someone, we take collective responsibility.”

Celtic as a club are seeking answers to what Desmond thinks is a question about mentality more than talent.

“Europe is so important,” he says, “as a yardstick of our football progression. On a sporting level, I think the Celtic team we have now is as good as at any time in the last 25 years, no doubt, and that’s even without a player like Henrik Larsson. If you asked me if the Celtic team today would beat the one that reached (the 2003 UEFA Cup final in) Seville, I’d say, ‘Yes’.”

The Athletic suggests then-manager Martin O’Neill might not agree with that view. Desmond responds, laughing: “Martin would disagree with anything that disagrees with him. Martin would tell you that without Larsson or Chris Sutton or Lennon, the rest were rubbish. So I’ve got eight against three.

“So I don’t think the quality of football has deteriorated. What we’ve got to learn is to cope with the pressure of playing in Europe. That’s what I’d say and I think that’s a psychological thing rather than a competitive thing. If you talk about the matches we lost in the past couple of years in the Champions League, they were lost despite us dominating possession, or whatever other measure you want to use – except goalscoring.

“And that is something I think is more of a psychological blockage than our football capability. That is something management have recognised and we will do something about it.”

How will Celtic do that?

“We will address it by asking what the fear factor is in Europe. We will learn how to get over the fear of failure by bringing in experts to help us.”

But when Celtic were progressive in Europe, surely there was pressure? Is it not to do with talent?

“Well, it has to do with talent; you also need a bit of luck – when we got to Seville that year, we had some lucky results. I attended all those matches, home and away, and we had luck at times.

“And you need belief. We had people who were extremely confident – Henrik, Chris Sutton, Neil Lennon were confident. They were leaders. Martin could instil confidence in people who shouldn’t be confident, had no right to be confident. He was magical at that.

Gordon (Strachan) did a great job. Look at the players he had. When we narrowly went out, 1-0 against AC Milan (the eventual winners, in the 2006-07 Champions League last 16 after extra time), you look at the centre-backs. I think Darren O’Dea played that night. Gordon was a motivator, a tactician, a strategist, as was Martin. But, again, I’d say we have a better squad now than then. Much better.”

If so, how does that explain the Ferencvaros result?

“I know their manager, Serhiy Rebrov, said we were the best footballing team they’d played in the last couple of years. He said he would not like to play us again. Andriy Shevchenko relayed his opinion to me.

“Their counter-attack was the difference. That happens. It’s not down to Lenny (now-manager Lennon). Brendan (Rodgers) had the same difficulty. He had the atmospheric pressure of the fans, their anxiety, their requirement for us to progress in Europe and it can be a burden on players. Their feeling does move onto the pitch, that angst. But we’ve to face it, recognise it and do something about it.

“I don’t think personnel is the issue. The (Celtic) personnel were better than the opposition. I think it is inexperience and a fear factor, a fear of failure, and we’ve got to do something about it. Sometimes, whether you’re a tennis player, a golfer, a footballer, there are mental blockages and what we’ve to do is find a route around them.”

There was disquiet among Celtic’s support at the Ferencvaros exit. Lennon is an authentic Celtic hero but he does not enjoy the coaching prestige Rodgers had during his near three years at Parkhead. Lennon had preceded Rodgers as manager – with Ronny Deila in between the two – before going back to the club when Rodgers left for Leicester City. Desmond heard strong opinions on Lennon’s return.

“I know when we appointed Lenny there were Rangers fans who thought we were handing them the league, but we felt that he had done an extremely good job at Hibs and he was a Celtic man true and true. I have quite a few Rangers friends in business, all very nice people who subscribed to the former viewpoint. However, I did have a wager with a few of them, so I owe Lenny a night out.

“You underestimate Lenny at your peril. He’s a very intelligent individual, he’s got great awareness and integrity. As far as analysis is concerned, he doesn’t shy away from performances. I’d a discussion yesterday with him about winning 5-0 at Ross County. As a headline, 5-0 looks great, but it was terrible, it flattered us completely. Ross County hit the post twice, they held the ball for long periods and had many shots. We should have won but 2-1, not 5-0.

“Lenny is up for that, he’d give you that same analysis. That’s what I like about him, he’s not camouflaging underperformance. When we’re succeeding, he’s looking where it came from and it’s the same with poor performances. He wants to play entertaining, attacking football, and, like Brendan, it’s possession football. It’s about being able to consistently deliver that Celtic brand of football.”

Desmond and Lennon’s Ross County chat reveals a level of daily engagement from the former that will surprise a few in Scotland.

Rodgers’ departure for Leicester 18 months ago provoked outrage among a fanbase he had wooed and wowed. The general feeling was that Rodgers had taken Celtic up a level and that he would lead them to 10 in a row. There was shock and bitterness when Leicester seemed to be more attractive. It was a moment of rupture for the club, but Desmond says Celtic were ready for it.

“What the fans saw was a Celtic man coming to Parkhead. Brendan brought in his team, a system of playing and the players responded to him. As an ex-Liverpool manager he had gravitas, status. He also had the detail – ‘This is how we want to play’ – which the players took on board. He did a fantastic job and was highly professional in his approach to everything.

“He was approached the previous summer with an unbelievable offer from China. I mean, financially transformational for him. He told me about it. We talked it through and it didn’t come to pass for various reasons. But I knew then that it was always likely he was going to go, because he was undoubtedly going to be offered a more lucrative contract in the future.

“It should be stated that no Celtic player or manager ever earned as much as Brendan Rodgers. He was a quality individual who did a quality job.

“So we had prepared ourselves. We knew it was only a matter of time before clubs would make an offer because he is the commodity every club needs — a first-class manager.

“Lenny was always on our radar. Lenny has been a work in progress for us. He’s been that person we have kind-of tutored and he’s learned along the way. The advice we gave him he’s now realised was good advice, and he’s matured and everybody’s allowed to make mistakes. None of them were fatal.

“So we took him back in even though some of the fans thought it was a retrograde step. But you learn more from mistakes, it can change your personality, your modus operandi. We saw that with Lenny and he has repaid our belief in him.”

Desmond first became involved in Celtic, as a non-executive director, in 1995. Tommy Burns was the manager and Rangers were rampant – they were seven titles into their own nine-in-a-row league championships. Celtic were very much Glasgow’s poor relations.

“What happened in ’95 was that someone approached me saying Celtic were raising money, that the club was on the verge of going bankrupt,” Desmond explains. “Fergus McCann was raising £4 million to develop the squad and the ground.

“I looked at the numbers and I said, ‘It’s too little, they need more than that.’ I said they needed £8 million and I would put in the additional £4 million. That’s what I did. That’s how I got involved.

“No matter what company it is, they never raise enough money; because everyone is an optimist, including myself. We raised the money and then we did another issue around 2000. As I’ve said many times, our whole objective is to invest intellectual capital rather than financial capital. That’s why we’ve had really strong board members over the years, unbelievably strong management under our outstanding chief executive, Peter Lawwell, and we prudently manage our finances.

“We’ve adopted Mr Micawber economics, you know the one. Annual income: twenty pounds, annual expenditure: nineteen, nineteen and six, result: happiness. Annual income: twenty pounds, annual expenditure: twenty pounds ought and six, result: misery.’

“Going back to that period, the club was shell-shocked. It hadn’t performed well on the field, it was falling asunder financially. Fergus did a great job resurrecting the club from the ashes, without going into administration, putting his own money in. He was wise, a canny Scotsman, he got out with a profit and not many do that in a Scottish football club. I don’t know if anyone has ever done it.”

Across at Ibrox, Micawberism would have been mocked openly. Rangers’ owner David Murray had the opposite attitude, as Desmond recalls: “When I got involved, David Murray had said that for every five pounds Celtic spent, Rangers would spend 10.”

That had long-term issues for Rangers and would eventually lead to administration and their drop from Scotland’s top flight in 2012. Two cup ties aside, Rangers were out of Celtic’s sporting life for four years. Did Desmond miss them?

Laughing, he replies: “I missed them in an anxiety sense. If we’ve an Old Firm match, they ruin the three or four days before it, the morning of the match and it would have consequences for the next few days if we lost. I missed that anxiety.”

He is adamant “we’re not competing with Rangers, we’re competing with ourselves”, but adds: “To be absolutely honest about it, Rangers make Celtic better. Competition makes you better. They’re there, they’ve a very good manager in Steven Gerrard, they’ve a good team. We have our work cut out to beat them.”

The two clubs define each other. When pondering the highs and lows of the last 25 years, Desmond immediately mentions two Old Firm games – the first two of the O’Neill era from 2000, the 6-2 home win in the August and the 5-1 away defeat three months later.

“The 6-2, definitely,” he says. “The other side of it was the 5-1, when (Tore Andre) Flo scored. Another low point was Martin’s last league match, at Motherwell (a 2-1 defeat in May 2005). That was the lowest point. We lost the league there.”

O’Neill had been a landmark appointment in June 2000. Rangers had just won their 11th title in 12 years, with Celtic finishing 21 points adrift. The decision to bring Kenny Dalglish back to Parkhead, with John Barnes alongside, had not worked. Celtic’s board, thinking what to do next, had contacted Guus Hiddink. Then Desmond stepped in.

“In 2000, they were going to appoint Hiddink – after Barnes and Dalglish,” Desmond says. “The existing management were going to do that. I said, ‘If I am to be involved in the recruitment of a manager I want to meet him and look into his eyes.’

“I told (directors) Pat Sheehy and Brian Quinn that I was going to Seville to meet Hiddink (then at Real Betis) and would they come along because I valued their opinion. On the day we met, there was a lawyer in Switzerland ready to sign the Hiddink contract.

“When we met it was obvious to me that Hiddink didn’t have the requisite passion for the Celtic job. Both Pat and Brian agreed. On our return, it was decided that we would reorganise the board and management and we appointed Brian Quinn as chairman and subsequently headhunted Peter Lawwell. I took on the responsibility of looking for a new manager.

“I had asked Alex Ferguson to be manager of Celtic around 1997 and I offered to pay the money myself, twice the salary he was on at Manchester United. He said he would like to consider it, even though he had a Rangers background. He said, ‘I’d like to do it, to follow in the footsteps of Jock Stein,’ but he said his overriding ambition was to win the Champions League with Manchester United. In fact, my good friend JP McManus and I were his guests at the (1999) final in Barcelona, where he fulfilled his dream.

“In 2000, I went back and asked him if he was to pick his replacement at that time who would it be. He said there were three people: Dave O’Leary, Alan Curbishley and Martin O’Neill. I said the one I’m interested in is Martin O’Neill.

“I had previously asked a prominent broadcaster if Martin (then managing Leicester in the Premier League) would be interested in the job and I got a response in the negative. I then asked Alex if he would speak with Martin, to see if he would meet with me, and the response was that he would be very interested in meeting. So I met Martin for dinner and we got on very well. I introduced him to Pat and Brian and they also felt he was a remarkable individual, so we hired Martin.”

In his first season, O’Neill turned that 21-point deficit of 1999-2000 into a 15-point title-winning margin. Celtic were rejuvenated. In 2003 they reached that UEFA Cup final in Seville against Jose Mourinho’s Porto and there would be other famous European nights such as the victory over Barcelona in 2012.

What next? What is Desmond’s Celtic vision for 2025?

“I’d like to be able to say that in five years’ time our team is better than any of the great teams that were led by Martin, Gordon, Brendan and Lenny.”

Celtic are not the only team in green and white Desmond has an interest in.

Last October he was invited to invest in Dublin club Shamrock Rovers. It was a club he watched as a boy (selling match programmes) in the late 1950s and 1960s when Rovers would pack out their Milltown ground. He also saw another Dublin side, Drumcondra, face Atletico Madrid in the 1958 European Cup’s qualifiers.

“It appealed to me to invest in the club because after they went into a major decline, they were rescued by their supporters,” he says of Shamrock Rovers. “They built a whole new model: stadium, new training ground, under-age teams, developing a youth policy. They are trying to keep their young players at home and allow them to finish their education. I like that a lot. They’ve a very good young chief executive in there called Brendan Murray, who really impressed me. I decided to invest on certain terms.

“And they’ve the same jersey as Celtic, so no confusion. With Brexit, it could be good if Rovers develop some young players. We could trial them and vice versa, we could conversely send some of our players on loan. Co-operation, nothing formal.”

Rovers are ambitious, sit eight points clear at the top of the League of Ireland at mid-season and last night hosted AC Milan in a Europa League qualifier, losing 2-0.

But, as with Scotland, Irish domestic football faces challenges sporting and economic. Desmond likes the All-Island League idea proposed by businessman Kieran Lucid. It would bring clubs from both sides of the Irish border into one competition. But it has opponents on and off the pitch.

“If the structure is on an all-island basis, we could progress,” Desmond says of Irish football. “We have to look at the size of the island and replicate the rugby model. They have provinces and clubs, north and south, and they face each other on a weekly basis. While there are political and cultural differences, they are unified in developing the sport of rugby on the island of Ireland. I’d like to see that happening (in football).

“I’d like to see an all-island soccer team and then players wouldn’t have to pick allegiance and so on. We’d have something we could unify around. Is a Unionist any less of a Unionist because he supports an all-Ireland rugby team? I don’t think so. Is a Republican going to be less of a Republican because he supports an all-Ireland soccer team with Unionists playing on it? I don’t think so.”

He sees this in the context of a changing Ireland and a changing world and change isn’t stopping. Nor is Desmond.

“We have had an influx of people from all over. When I grew up, you saw no one from Europe or South America or Africa. Now we’ve a whole village of Brazilians in Ireland, Nigerians, Romanians, etc; we’re a confluence of nationalities. They have all got their culture and histories and we learnt to embrace these differences.

“Change happens because of leadership. The powers that be on both sides can make this happen. It is in everybody’s interest to make the island of Ireland a more competitive soccer force.”
Click to expand...

The Crow, Aug 1, 2025 at 7:19 PM

#901
Ryanm1984

Joined:

Jan 16, 2022

Messages:

4,417

Likes Received:

4,571

Fav Celtic Player:

Kyogo

The Crow said: ↑

Mind when Dermot said this

I’ll find the full interview and quote it again

What next? What is Desmond’s Celtic vision for 2025?

“I’d like to be able to say that in five years’ time our team is better than any of the great teams that were led by Martin, Gordon, Brendan and Lenny.”
Click to expand...

I'm sure he ment to say Tony and Ronnie

Ryanm1984, Aug 1, 2025 at 7:20 PM

#902

Fox#4 likes this.
The Crow Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Oct 6, 2012

Messages:

177,084

Likes Received:

104,910

Ryanm1984 said: ↑

I'm sure he ment to say Tony and Ronnie
Click to expand...

More than likely aye mate

The Crow, Aug 1, 2025 at 7:20 PM

#903
Ryanm1984

Joined:

Jan 16, 2022

Messages:

4,417

Likes Received:

4,571

Fav Celtic Player:

Kyogo

Desmond baffles me.

Talks of us doing great things and has personally appointed one of the best managers in Britain twice yet continually allows him to have his legs cut away from under him by that fat * Lawwell.

For a guy who's been such a successful businessman it's bizarre the amount of mismanagement he allows to go on at the club.

Clearly Rodgers isn't happy with how the club is progressing, if Desmond rates him so highly why isn't he asking his advice, ask him where we are failing compared to previous clubs Rodgers has worked at.

Surely someone as intelligent as him can see the need to modernise and see if he doesn't or if he doesn't have the desire to do it, then walk away

Ryanm1984, Aug 1, 2025 at 7:28 PM

#904

Mr Shelby, cidermaster, MynameisEarl and 2 others like this.
Blochairnbhoy

Joined:

Jan 26, 2017

Messages:

30,829

Likes Received:

22,871

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Scott Sinclair

Fav Celtic Song:

Grace

Made my feelings known the other night nothing changes these * need hunted!

Blochairnbhoy, Aug 1, 2025 at 7:40 PM

#905

cidermaster, Rydo1888*, Cumbernauld Bhoy67 and 4 others like this.
eire4

Joined:

Jan 5, 2006

Messages:

19,349

Likes Received:

9,208

Location:

Chicago USA

Fav Celtic Player:

Henrik Larsson
Blochairnbhoy said: ↑

Made my feelings known the other night nothing changes these * need hunted!
Click to expand...

Could not agree more. The fact that we are going into the opening game of the season this weekend with a lineup that is weaker then finished last season and less quality in the squad depth wise on top of that is a disgrace. To say we need new forward thinking minded people on our board is quite the understatement to say the least.
eire4, Aug 1, 2025 at 8:50 PM

#906

cidermaster, Guchi Gucci and Blochairnbhoy like this.

Blochairnbhoy

Joined:

Jan 26, 2017

Messages:

30,829

Likes Received:

22,871

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Scott Sinclair

Fav Celtic Song:

Grace

What's the bets to compound everything when the UCL draw is made on monday we then take a decision to postpone the livingston home game and you will have had people pay for flights/accommodation etc

Blochairnbhoy, Aug 1, 2025 at 8:58 PM

#907
Guchi Gucci Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Jul 6, 2010

Messages:

1,489

Likes Received:

1,356

It's wild how quickly we can sell players. Shocking state.

Guchi Gucci, Aug 2, 2025 at 12:20 AM

#908

Sgt Neppers* likes this.
Mr Shelby Moderator Moderator Gold Member

Joined:

Jan 7, 2012

Messages:

55,366

Likes Received:

44,196

Location:

West Lothian

Fav Celtic Player:

Larsson. Forever and always.

Fav Celtic Song:

Symphony

Twisty said: ↑

Full club just seems run poorly from the colts, to the womens team, to the tv channel .... just about everything. So much more could be done with the money we have lying around, just seems bare minimum across the board to keep things respectable.

The Celtic Way and new training facility seem like the only stand out things they've done recently. More could be done to make the external of the ground more pleasing on the eye. What happened to the museum ?
Click to expand...

Rumours that museum and hotel would cost £250m. Which I find hard to believe. But anyway.

Desmond won't pay for it out his own pocket.

Mr Shelby, Aug 2, 2025 at 12:26 AM

#909
Dianbobo Balde

Joined:

Jan 3, 2025

Messages:

502

Likes Received:

434

Fav Celtic Player:

Bobo Balde

Fav Celtic Song:

Celtic Symphony
Its kind of just long past time I think the board became more transparent about their strategy, opened up communication with the fanbase and set out some tangible targets.

As long as they accumulate and sit on large cash reserves then the circle of mistrust and resentment between board and fanbase continues - and it does neither any favours.

Since we have been dominating the domestic scene, the titles won have prevented this from spilling over. But you could see from the covid year how quickly the fans are prepared to turn on the board if things go badly. I think it would only take not winning the title for it to get explosive again because there is no goodwill and deep mistrust there.

The board will call it entitled fan behaviour but they know how the relationship stands right now. They know the fans view and what is grating at them. The see everything from pundits to media to the manager questioning their ambition and their strategy constantly. But they still choose not to engage or communicate and to let this fester.

If they are confident in what they are doing and that their strategy is correct - then why not at least attempt engage with the fans on it on at least a high level. E.G:

Whats their rationale for the current cash reserves?

Is it purely held as a safetly net?

If so - how much cash reserves do they think are needed? Why?

Are there any plans to utilise the cash reserves?

Is there are an amount they are trying to get to before they will change strategy?

Is there any commitment to re-invest a certain % of player sale revenue? If not why?

Is there any commitment to reaching a benchmark in Europe? What kind of spending are they prepared to commit to that?

You may not like or agree with the answers given but if there was a better understanding of why the board are pursuing the strategy they are and if the board were actually able to make some genuine commitments it would reduce a lot of the negative noise that occurs pretty much every window now.
Dianbobo Balde, Aug 2, 2025 at 12:58 AM

#910

eire4 likes this.
Hope N Ur Heart

Joined:

Jan 11, 2009

Messages:

2,488

Likes Received:

3,259

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Jimmy Johnstone followed closely by Henrik

Fav Celtic Song:

Them all!!

Looks like the Board acknowledge the coaching skills of BR and how he can nurture and improve players.However its also obvious they dont have confidence in his ability to get value for money(i.e.Trusty 6m,Idah 9m,Engels 11m).
Still, got a month to go for transfers...along with more scrutiny and sniping to come from the media.

Hope N Ur Heart, Aug 2, 2025 at 2:29 AM

#911
oh bhoy

Joined:

Jul 26, 2010

Messages:

7,647

Likes Received:

5,030

bring back dom mckay ! who would have thought signing so many good players in one summer would get you your marching orders

oh bhoy, Aug 2, 2025 at 5:20 AM

#912
Ryanm1984

Joined:

Jan 16, 2022

Messages:

4,417

Likes Received:

4,571

Fav Celtic Player:

Kyogo

Hope N Ur Heart said: ↑

Looks like the Board acknowledge the coaching skills of BR and how he can nurture and improve players.However its also obvious they dont have confidence in his ability to get value for money(i.e.Trusty 6m,Idah 9m,Engels 11m).
Still, got a month to go for transfers...along with more scrutiny and sniping to come from the media.
Click to expand...

Those 3 guys cost as much as they did bcoz we had to pay a premium do to the board waiting until the last 2 weeks of the window to get them.

Yet as usual they don't learn and here we are again into August with big businesses still needing done.

Ryanm1984, Aug 2, 2025 at 7:57 AM

#913

eire4 likes this.
Skelleto

Joined:

Sep 21, 2010

Messages:

10,011

Likes Received:

5,030

Location:

Sweden

Fav Celtic Song:

Boys of the old brigade

Hope N Ur Heart said: ↑

Looks like the Board acknowledge the coaching skills of BR and how he can nurture and improve players.However its also obvious they dont have confidence in his ability to get value for money(i.e.Trusty 6m,Idah 9m,Engels 11m).
Still, got a month to go for transfers...along with more scrutiny and sniping to come from the media.
Click to expand...

I listened ro Tusdale soeak about helping Celtic with rhose signings before joining the club officialy, so that was him. At least who held the negotiations.

Skickat från min SM-F956B via Tapatalk

Skelleto, Aug 2, 2025 at 8:03 AM

#914
dbhoy72

Joined:

Feb 9, 2014

Messages:

22,793

Likes Received:

7,640

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Lubo

Fav Celtic Song:

Willie Maley

PL - "You watching this Dermo?"
DD - "Aye, they look pretty pish Pedro, don't ya think?"
PL - "Told you Dezzo, just close the tin mate!"
DD - "Cheers Ped, see ya tomorrow"

dbhoy72, Aug 2, 2025 at 8:07 PM

#915

themouth1888 and Sgt Neppers* like this.
Sentinel

Joined:

Jun 30, 2012

Messages:

4,677

Likes Received:

2,544

I really hope the crowd gives them an absolute roasting if they stick their weasely little heads up from their bunkers tomorrow.

Sentinel, Aug 2, 2025 at 8:49 PM

#916

TheHappyLoss likes this.
john2061

Joined:

Jan 21, 2010

Messages:

6,275

Likes Received:

4,548

dbhoy72 said: ↑

PL - "You watching this Dermo?"
DD - "Aye, they look pretty pish Pedro, don't ya think?"
PL - "Told you Dezzo, just close the tin mate!"
DD - "Cheers Ped, see ya tomorrow"
Click to expand...

PL- oh by the way Dermot will put a padlock on the tin .
DD- let's play it safe Peter just weld it shut

john2061, Aug 2, 2025 at 9:02 PM

#917

themouth1888 likes this.
Sgt Neppers*

Joined:

Jan 14, 2008

Messages:

7,790

Likes Received:

13,889

Location:

Edinburgh

Sgt Neppers*, Aug 2, 2025 at 9:02 PM

#918

Mr Shelby likes this.
The Crow Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Oct 6, 2012

Messages:

177,084

Likes Received:

104,910

Article from Paul Larkin on Substack

Normally when you do a piece asking any sort of questions of Celtic you always get a few people spitting the dummy and at least one Celtic employee trying to deflect.
Not so with my last piece.
As well as my biggest numbers ever on here, I got constant praise and several Celtic employees nodding in agreement.
Uncharted territory for me I can tell you!
A bit more digging and it’s clear there’s been a breakdown at Celtic.
My understanding is there are six players lined up but Dermot Desmond has refused to sanction any of them. As I’ve said in a few articles, I’ve been told time and again that Desmond has already stood down Peter Lawwell and, by some accounts, the PR Department (I say department; there’s two of them) and therefore no briefing is going on at all.
One of my many bug bears regarding Desmond is the way he acts like he owns the club. He doesn’t. In fact, if he he bought 100% of the shares then he could do what he wanted, whether we liked it or not but he hasn’t so he can’t.
Where this leaves the future of Michael Nicholson and Chris McKay I don’t know. Their stand off attitude with fans and seeming unwillingness to stand up to Desmond has already alienates a lot of the support(for all Lawwell’s faults, he could and did stand up to Desmond)
Then there is the manager. I believe if he hadn’t committed to three years then he would be gone by now. (Listen, the guy is loaded, relatively young and doesn’t need the hassle of trying to manage with two hands tied behind his back)
Which all leads to Celtic entering a season much weaker than last. This is all opinion and you’ll have noticed, like me, the reluctance from anyone at Celtic TV, the View and so on to ask the manager anything about new signings, but I think we need a goalkeeper, left back, centre half, centre mid, winger and striker.
Which leads me back to Desmond.What is he playing at? Because right now it seems like Golf and funny buggers.

The Crow, Aug 2, 2025 at 9:41 PM

#919

Mr Shelby likes this.
evilbunny1991

Joined:

Feb 2, 2010

Messages:

9,431

Likes Received:

843

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

KI

Fav Celtic Song:

Let the People Sing

See the thing is I’m not really sure that Desmond can actually make those decisions and stop transfers from taking place. He is not a majority shareholder and we are not a private company. He himself cannot unilaterally do those things I think. Now he may hold enough sway over enough board members to stop things from happening.

We have a CEO and CFO and a board who together make operational decisions. Clearly too many on our board as well as our CEO have shat their pants and just won’t stand up to him. A shareholder should have absolutely no say in operational decisions, that is for full time employees to make.

evilbunny1991, Aug 2, 2025 at 9:54 PM

#920

(You must log in or sign up to reply here.)

Page 46 of 47

change consent