Having trouble logging in by clicking the link at the top right of the page? Click here to be taken to the log in page.
Dismiss Notice

Celtic Transfers 2024

Discussion in 'Celtic Chat' started by Callum McGregor, Oct 30, 2023.

Discuss Celtic Transfers 2024 in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.

Page 458 of 538

bhoy_wonder Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Aug 11, 2010

Messages:

8,695

Likes Received:

6,795

Location:

Belfast, Antrim

Fav Celtic Player:

King of kings

Fav Celtic Song:

JCGE

It's going to be an anxious 10 days until this window closes for this bear.

bhoy_wonder, Aug 22, 2024

#9141
DonnyCelt

Joined:

Jul 21, 2010

Messages:

13,269

Likes Received:

13,224

Can see this being an even worse summer than last.

DonnyCelt, Aug 22, 2024

#9142

Blochairnbhoy likes this.
HTG "I have an uncle who does Yoga"

Joined:

Dec 28, 2016

Messages:

11,726

Likes Received:

12,770

Fav Celtic Player:

CCV

Fav Celtic Song:

Let the people sing

LB, CB, Winger, CM x2 and a ST.

Essentially what we need, I can survive without the second CM coming in but 5 players in 10 days is a lot to ask.

Massive 20 days ahead.

HTG, Aug 22, 2024

#9143
The Thumb

Joined:

Mar 27, 2015

Messages:

11,442

Likes Received:

5,784

Location:

The North.

Fav Celtic Song:

The Celtic Song

Supposedly Millwall are complaining thst we've been slow with the paperwork with Daniel Kelly..

Typical glacial pace

The Thumb, Aug 22, 2024

#9144
Mr Shelby Moderator Moderator Gold Member

Joined:

Jan 7, 2012

Messages:

52,125

Likes Received:

37,906

Location:

West Lothian

Fav Celtic Player:

Larsson. Forever and always.

Fav Celtic Song:

Symphony

The Thumb said: ↑

Supposedly Millwall are complaining thst we've been slow with the paperwork with Daniel Kelly..

Typical glacial pace
Click to expand...

Fax machine playing up again

Mr Shelby, Aug 22, 2024

#9145

Jaxxx likes this.
Luis1967 Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

May 15, 2010

Messages:

18,494

Likes Received:

7,372

Location:

Scotland

Not watching the game the now but would quite happily take Moi back. He’s a player. Que someone about to tell me he’s having a stinker

Luis1967, Aug 22, 2024

#9146

Shen likes this.
Mr Shelby Moderator Moderator Gold Member

Joined:

Jan 7, 2012

Messages:

52,125

Likes Received:

37,906

Location:

West Lothian

Fav Celtic Player:

Larsson. Forever and always.

Fav Celtic Song:

Symphony

HTG said: ↑

LB, CB, Winger, CM x2 and a ST.

Essentially what we need, I can survive without the second CM coming in but 5 players in 10 days is a lot to ask.

Massive 20 days ahead.
Click to expand...

If we can secure 2 by Monday, I think 4 by Friday night is doable if we know who we want. Which even by this stage and even by our standards, we should know.

Bogusz and another by Sunday then the remaining 4 rest of the week. By that point MOR will be gone and I'd imagine we have more clarity on Kyogo.

Mr Shelby, Aug 22, 2024

#9147

Celts88 and Random Review like this.
Sentinel

Joined:

Jun 30, 2012

Messages:

4,137

Likes Received:

2,164

Sgt Neppers* said: ↑

We're going in the final week of the window needing 5.....

That's not taking into account Kyogo or MOR going. Struggling to see the positives here.

Edit: flip side. Selling Kyogo and MOR and not replacing them with genuine quality would see a revolt and Rodgers walk (potentially), so there has to be a few signings coming in.
Click to expand...

Revolt?! Haha, you've got to be having a laugh mate. We're lobsters. Been brought up to temperature over the years so we don't even care when we've been boiled alive by the PLC..

There should be thousands outside CP right now demanding the board resign.

Sentinel, Aug 22, 2024

#9148

oh bhoy and Sgt Neppers* like this.
muaythai postie

Joined:

Sep 5, 2008

Messages:

4,068

Likes Received:

2,556

Location:

glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

lubo

DonnyCelt said: ↑

Can see this being an even worse summer than last.
Click to expand...

I honestly didn't think it could get any worse and then the winter window had me deflated as * .if we don't strengthen and I mean spend some serious Dosh on real quality then the agenda is quite clear from the Celtic board..they don't give a * about the footballing side as long as the bank account has a * load of money sitting in it.

muaythai postie, Aug 22, 2024

#9149

DonnyCelt likes this.
Blochairnbhoy

Joined:

Jan 26, 2017

Messages:

28,800

Likes Received:

20,927

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Scott Sinclair

Fav Celtic Song:

Grace

bhoy_wonder said: ↑

It's going to be an anxious 10 days until this window closes for this bear.
Click to expand...

8 days

Blochairnbhoy, Aug 22, 2024

#9150
Blochairnbhoy

Joined:

Jan 26, 2017

Messages:

28,800

Likes Received:

20,927

Location:

Glasgow

Fav Celtic Player:

Scott Sinclair

Fav Celtic Song:

Grace
A year ago just now we went into the last week window wanting 5 it was widely reported

1 centre back
1 left back
1 striker
1 winger
1 CM

We got 3 of the 5 with the other 2 changing their mind on the final day.

Could easily happen again
Blochairnbhoy, Aug 22, 2024

#9151

Notorious Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Oct 6, 2012

Messages:

167,875

Likes Received:

96,632

Blochairnbhoy said: ↑

8 days
Click to expand...

Thanks big ben

Notorious, Aug 22, 2024

#9152

Dannybhoy81 and Blochairnbhoy like this.
Jaxxx Orchestrated Sonic Attacker Gold Member

Joined:

Sep 5, 2014

Messages:

774

Likes Received:

1,190

Location:

Inverness

Mr Shelby said: ↑

If we sign 7 players in the remaining days of good quality I'll get a Peter lawwell tattoo. All is forgiven.

Till January.
Click to expand...

Bookmarked

Jaxxx, Aug 22, 2024

#9153

Celts88, ThatBhoyLarsson, Mr Shelby and 2 others like this.
Notorious Gold Member Gold Member

Joined:

Oct 6, 2012

Messages:

167,875

Likes Received:

96,632

Looking forward to the late news

Notorious, Aug 22, 2024

#9154

Jaxxx likes this.
Officer Doofy Come to me, human man Gold Member

Joined:

Jul 5, 2011

Messages:

62,106

Likes Received:

32,886

Mr Shelby said: ↑

If we sign 7 players in the remaining days of good quality I'll get a Peter lawwell tattoo. All is forgiven.

Till January.
Click to expand...

Tattoo not coming.

Officer Doofy, Aug 22, 2024

#9155

Mr Shelby and Jaxxx like this.
Random Review

Joined:

Aug 31, 2012

Messages:

22,455

Likes Received:

9,243

Location:

Indonesia

Fav Celtic Player:

Jinky (ever) Lubo (modern era), KT (current)

Fav Celtic Song:

Fields of Athenry

Celtic_Daft1888 said: ↑

I don't really see it as optimism and I'm absolutely not trying to sound like I'm trying to * folk off but it just seems like common sense to me. I get there are fans who are rightly annoyed about the lack of transfer activity so far. They're paying customers who are allowed to feel whatever they want. I prefer to see myself as a kind off middle shooter on this forum, where I will lay into the club when I feel it's needed, like I did after both windows last season but I'm smart enough to know that it's not as simple as FIFA or Football Manager and things do take time, especially when you're targeting a specific type of signing.

Now, does that mean we couldn't have been quicker? Of course not. I wasn't happy with the speed of the Bernardo deal, especially. I believed it became a bit of a joke, every day for about 7/8 days we seemed to get the same update from Portugal, from a completely different source. We seemed to have had that £3.5m deal with add ons agreed about 5 or 6 times and then we had agreed terms for about another 2/3 days. So yeah, I was * off. With Idah, I believe Norwich were trying to take the * and what pushed that deal on was the injury to Kyogo. I think Celtic would be still sitting, waiting for Norwich to accept a deal of around £6m/£7m if Kyogo hadn't have been feeling iffy with the shoulder. I believe it became a case of, who blinks first and Celtic were the ones to blink. Norwich were quite happy to sell for £10m, we didn't want to pay that much and again, it became a bit of a joke, which we were part of. I'm not against trying to get the best deal possible for players but I agree, there needs to be a fair balancing act. You either give them a date and move on, or you give them a date and match the fee or come to agreeable terms, quickly.

As I said in another post, even targeting players excelling in obscurer leagues is going to get far more difficult. Nanasi from the Swedish League is about to join Strasbourg for £9m. He's had what? A decent half season... £9m. That's a lot of money and we could pay that and still be taking a huge risk. So, I get why the club are in a bit of a limbo this window, where we are overly relying on Rodgers, who really only has a working knowledge of the English Market and we may go off some recommendations from scouts/agents but allow Rodgers the opportunity to carry out enough due diligence on signings, like we seem to have done with Bogusz. Then, you see a young midfielder like Engels, who seems to be breaking into the first team for a Bundesliga team, 20 years old so huge potential and he's available for a similar price? Great, £9m would be very well spent. Now, what's his terms? Can we make the deal work? He seems keen to join us, he seems like he would be affordable with terms. But even that is a risk. The boy has played 50 games for Augsburg, most of them off the subs bench. So again, it's a different type of risk.

As has been discussed multiple times on this forum, until the club upgrade the footballing department, we are going to be running of recommendations from our managers, agents/scouts/city group to get us out of transfer stickiness and I have a massive problem with that. We need a Director of Football AND a Head of Recruitment and a complete overhaul of our scouting department because they're not good enough.
Click to expand...

This is such a good post!

Random Review, Aug 22, 2024

#9156

Mr Shelby likes this.
Random Review

Joined:

Aug 31, 2012

Messages:

22,455

Likes Received:

9,243

Location:

Indonesia

Fav Celtic Player:

Jinky (ever) Lubo (modern era), KT (current)

Fav Celtic Song:

Fields of Athenry

DonnyCelt said: ↑

Can see this being an even worse summer than last.
Click to expand...

It's already a better summer than last year.

Random Review, Aug 22, 2024

#9157

Celts88 likes this.
Mr Shelby Moderator Moderator Gold Member

Joined:

Jan 7, 2012

Messages:

52,125

Likes Received:

37,906

Location:

West Lothian

Fav Celtic Player:

Larsson. Forever and always.

Fav Celtic Song:

Symphony

Jaxxx said: ↑

Bookmarked
Click to expand...

If my account disappears next Friday at 11pm you'll know why.

Mr Shelby, Aug 22, 2024

#9158

Jaxxx and Celts88 like this.
thailandceltic From Immigration to Domination

Joined:

May 4, 2008

Messages:

21,041

Likes Received:

14,135

Location:

Baile Ath Cliath

Fav Celtic Player:

Paddy

Fav Celtic Song:

hail hail

The Thumb said: ↑

Supposedly Millwall are complaining thst we've been slow with the paperwork with Daniel Kelly..

Typical glacial pace
Click to expand...

Good... * Millwall

thailandceltic, Aug 22, 2024

#9159

Celts88, Gabriel, Dannybhoy81 and 1 other person like this.
TheHappyLoss

Joined:

Jul 14, 2013

Messages:

13,317

Likes Received:

8,614

Location:

209

Surely to * even we couldn’t lose our three best players in the last week of the window?

TheHappyLoss, Aug 22, 2024

#9160

(You must log in or sign up to reply here.)

Page 458 of 538

change consent