Maloney Threads (Merged)

i think we shud welcome him bak

fair enuff he left but evry1 makes mistakes

put him nd mcgeady on the wings robson/brown nd hartley/ donati(if he settles) in the middle its a gd midfield

or why not gethim for bak up nd hav brown, mcgeady,robson nd hartley in the middle with donati nd maloney on the bench

 

can't read help need text language translator

 

Signing Mahoney would be a step in the wrong direction

 

Agreed, * him.

 

How can a player that adds quality to the team a step in the wrong direction people need to forgive him as he seems to realise hes made a huge mistake & if he rejoins give him there backing to help celtic to 4inarow

 

He is not good enough! If we want to see Celtic progress to the last 16 or 8 of the CL then we have to go for real quality players and pay the price. If you want to see Celtic languish in home Cup Competitions then take back the has beens! He was never class and never will be a class player, he was and still is average.

Time to adjust our sights and look elsewhere.

 

he proved he could put a shift in in the CL when he was with us during strachans team 2 & was one of our star players in a season we made the last 16 already so i dont see why he wont benifit this time as he can be used as compition for places or to replace naka or mcgeady during later on in the game

 

He is generally deployed as an attacking midfielder or striker. He has tremendous pace and a great eye for a goal.

Season 2007 - 08

In season 2008 he scored 6 goals

Competition Appearances 11 and 11 as sub. Quality player then!

FA Cup Apps 0 (zero)

League Cup Apps 2

So who do Villa want to replace him?

No a bad wee player but not brilliant either, FFS no again!

 

he is a good player but the thing i wonder about is that MON barely used him at celtic, preferring pearson, miller and mcgeady as the younger players. strachan on the other hand brought maloney in to his team and until his injury was a permanent fixture. why then would he leave to be with MON again? at villa he has had few opportunities again.

the other thing is that he has undoubted talent but doesnt apply himself, often looking disinterested. he barely uses his pace, doesnt take on players on the left, doesnt cross on the right and doesnt make run when played through the middle. he cracks the odd shot and takes some free kicks. i would like to sign him but have to like the terms.

ps. i still think he is like donnelly. came through the youth system, wide man/ striker, left for money to go down south where it isnt really working out.

 

should take him back,maybe on loan for a season first??would giev good backup to aiden and naka

 

Going by my maths thats more than a goal everyother game & he isnt getting much time on the pitch so he cant be bad & atleast we know he can hack it in the spl unlike signings such as sno donati tommy G & jarosik

 

I still remember his screamer against Rangers, rom where I was sitting it looked miles away - but Klos was nowhere near it.

He's quite a strong wee * from all that time spent in the gym when injured & I think his tackling back is pretty good too.

Don't think I could stomach paying 4mill for a player that was on our books a season & a half ago though!!

 

he was good enough to win player of the year.

il be surprised if we sign anyone better than shaun this summer. just a load of sour grapes from people who are still * off that he left

 

Sunderland are linked with him in mirror today for 4mill, wouldnt pay that

 

I couldnt give a * if he leaves Villa as he is not coming back to Celtic.

In all honesty, I really dont think WGS would want to bring him back.

 

i'd take any player who would improve the team and think SM would do this, it would have to be for the right price as not to effect the transfer kitty for the other wordclass players were gonna buy..LOL

Biggest name in european football, they tricked us there alrite JVOH

 

ROY KEANE IS BUYING HIM !!!!!!!

 

* him

im sick of players moving to smaller clubs claiming that they are doing it to enhance their careers.....then when it all goes pete tong they are dying to get bak to us....he went for the cash....couldnt hack it.....now he wants to use us as his safety net.....let the huns have him.....if he goes there hes a bigger * than i thought.....* him

 

* him he had his chance dont want him back