Player Ratings

i would say

Boruc - 8 - Made some great saves
Cawldwell - 8 - amazing all night
kennedy - 5 - sold the goal then got taken off
mcmanus- 9 made important tackles
naylor - 7 - great until taken off
mcgeady - 9 - kept the game alive all the time
brown - 9 - same as mcgeady but made more challenges
jarosik - 9 - great goal he has really changed in recent weeks i feel he now deserves to wear a celtic jersy
hartley - 10 played great in all positions
mcdonald - 7 - ran about all night never stopped
jvoh - 5 - pish

Subs
donati - 8 - great goal and nice passes
killen - 6 - came on and done more in 10 mins than jvoh done in the full game
elvis - 7 - solid

what do you guys think?

 

Boruc - 8
Caldwell - 9
kennedy - 3
mcmanus- 8
naylor - 7
mcgeady - 9
brown - 9
jarosik - 9
hartley - 9
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 5

Subs
donati - 8
killen - 6
elvis - 7

 

mine are:
boruc-7 made 1 great save that i can remember and then didnt have much else to do
caldwell-8 good gonig forards made some poor crosses and was always an option
kennedy-5 gifted the goal and still was caught out of position, made 1 good block
macmanus-7 solid
naylor-6 not much 2 say but injury
hartley-7 did well out of posiotion, no left foot was a weak side and tryed to paly it a bit to much
mcgeady-8 good runs, great at the end and soem great balls
jj-7 great goal but should of got maybe another 2 didnt do to much else i think
brown-9 was excellent, great running, great tackles, great passes
mcdonald-7 was great at runnnig running down but didnt get any shooting chances
JVOH-7 made flicks on and ran a bit looks to his better form

dontai-7 goal made this happen apart from that not much else i think look to casual
pressley-7 looked good and deserves to start
killen-6 avaerage noting to say about

 

Boruc - 8
Caldwell - 9
kennedy - 4
mcmanus- 8
naylor - 7
mcgeady - 8
brown - 8
jarosik - 9
hartley - 8
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 6

Subs
donati - 8
killen - 6
elvis - 8

 

Boruc - 7
Caldwell - 9.5 (played amazingly tonight, seemed to be everywhere)
kennedy - 3
mcmanus- 7
naylor - 6
mcgeady - 9
brown - 7
jarosik - 9
hartley - 8
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 4

Subs
donati - 9
killen - 5
elvis - 7

 

Boruc - 8
Caldwell - 8
kennedy - 4
mcmanus- 8
naylor - 6
mcgeady - 8
brown - 8
jarosik - 10
hartley - 9
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 6

Subs
donati - 9
killen - 6
elvis - 8

 

Yeah Definatly
Jarosik Had A Great Game
Elvis Did Well When He Came On
Donati Was In And Out Of The Game!
But In The End Great Performace All Round
Pity About Naylor And Kennedy

 

How can you rate JVOH so badly, he won 90% of the balls in the air, made numerous flick-ons throughout the night.* me, he even ran about and made some tackles.
He's a target man, he done his job.

JVOH 7/8

 

it just wasn't his game.

 

lol what does that mean?

 

Nah a doubt it m8 he was always slow off the mark andd 90% of the headers he won were all fouls so what is the use in that

 

agree with you mate

 

How can you not know what that means??
It wasn't his game-- a.k.a he didnt play his best in the game... a.k.a he looked tired...

 

Boruc - 8
Caldwell - 9
kennedy - 4
mcmanus- 8
naylor - 6
mcgeady - 7
brown - 8
jarosik - 8
hartley - 9
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 5

Subs
donati - 7
killen - 5
elvis - 7

 

The ref was a disgrace tonite, every time a celtic player made a challenge he would say it was a foul.
He doesnt have any pace, yes but what do you expect from a target man- tonite he done his job, won headers and connected pretty well with McDonald.
I'm not saying he was amaing but he doesnt deserve some of the * ratings being given in this thread.

 

Your right, he didnt play his best game but he done a * of alot better than the * rating you gave him. He look tired? maybe due to the fact hes just back from injury.....

 

everyone was good apart from kennedy jj was fantastic best hes pld imo unlucky not to score another hartley is just a hero just now he will play anywhere hes asked and do a decent job.

caldwell i hope will shut up some of the people who say he doesnt deserve to be in the team i think hes a decent player. in a way im also glad we left it late to score the winner cos it doesnt give them any time to come back.

mon the fucken hoops

 

WHen is a target man not ment to have pace ? ? isnt my fault the ref was against him. jvoh gave away too many fouls when we were attacking and pilling on the pressure and he couldnt have connected that well with mcdonald because i dont think mcdonald had the many shots so you are just talking out you *

 

I,m not blamin in this thread but naylor gave a terrible ball forward when it was punted straight back up for the jfk howler....hope to * the lad is ok..

 

Boruc - 7
Caldwell - 7
kennedy - 5
mcmanus- 7
naylor - 4
mcgeady - 6
brown - 7
jarosik - 8
hartley - 7
mcdonald - 7
jvoh - 1

Subs
donati - 8
killen - 1
elvis - 6

sick of hesselink now

it's not working