[Link] Negotiations with Tomasz Kuszczak

Not seen enough of him to be honest but why are most against him signing? Fergie must've thought he was good enough for man u at 1 point!

 

Really don't rate him. Never understood how he managed to get a move to Utd in the first place.

 

he is worse than zaluska.

 

*! I'd rather keep Zaluska than bring him in as no1

 

Tomasz Kuszczak would be a great signing.

 

He's a good shot stopper but his concentration is shocking. He's no different from Zaluska. I don't think he's got the mentality for a big club.

I AGREE WITH THAT STATEMENT. HE LIKES A MISTAKE AND WAS NEVER IN THE SAME LEAGUE AS BORUC.

 

I would take him. He could benefit from playing consistantly. You can't fully judge a player untill you see him play for us. How many "flops" have we signed and turned into superstars. We have to take a gamble with this one. Would prefer him to Cudicini, at least Tomasz will have a greater re-sale value if it doesn't work.

 

* no!

There's better out there - as noted we've already declined to sign better GKs!

No, no, no!

 

Hes a good keeper and would be excellent at this level, much better than zaluska.

 

But is that through finance or them not wanting to come? This could just be scraping the barrel of the few goalkeepers available now that we can afford and would be willing to play SPL football.
I think we've got ourselves in a hole with the keeper situation, could just get stuck with Zaluska (if this happens i'll support him but won't be happy) or potentially take a punt on someone who isn't settled where they are like Kuszczak, you never know if he settles he could be class.

 

better than a free stipe?

 

So many utter nonsense comments on here from people who have barely seen him play.

 

According to NL and the coaching staff I guess.

 

He's a clown.

 

watch the mooth, it's Craig Gordon guys

 

That from your inside source?

 

Was actually very good at west brom but has been brutal at united

 

So what is the general Man United consensus on him?

 

any time i've seen him he's been poor would rather we got pletikosa

 

Some games was fine and he was a joke some he was outstanding but it's hard to judge him hardly got a run of games can say the same about Tim Howard /Ben Foster both was fine keepers just not good enough to be number 1 at Man Utd but that does not make them bad keepers at all.

I would take both of the above in a heart beat i think Pig is getting a lot of stick on here based on what people saw from him based on the Blackburn game .

Like the two above they made mistake but then moved on and with game time they improved and i feel Tomasz Kuszczak needs a move to do the same .

loan view to buying him could turn out fantastic business.