Paul Caddis

this boy has great potential, but not as a rb i think his position is right midfield if we play him there we might have a we gem in our hands. hope some of you guys can see it too.

 

Average to decent player. Too small to make it in his preferred position though

 

not good enough, when he did get a few gamesi wasnt impressed at all, him and wilson cant pass at all and punt it up the pitch alot

 

Like James_Bhoy said, he was given a lot of chances this season with Hinkel being out but he was pure pish!! Not good enough for Celtic but would be a good player for the likes of Dundee Utd.

 

a handfull of good performances = not good enough for celtic , we need players that plays good performances week in week out not every so often , great guy but time to move on.

 

Good squad player but no way a starting RB for us he's much more suited to a winger role than RB but even then I'd just have him as cover not a starter.

 

He's good
He potentially could be really good
He's not better than Hinkel (or any of our wingers)
So he shall reside on the bench until his chance pops up

 

I feel sorry for the kid if he does not get a chance you cant blame the bhoy if he wants out of Celtic , Think his best position is a right winger .

 

no time for sentiment bottom line is hes not good enough.he went to dundee utd and got a game at start then fell away,move him on its players like him at cp that are not good enough,we need a better quality of player

 

I would say that both Andreas Hinkel and Mark Wilson are better right-backs than Paul Caddis is. I would also say that Aiden McGeady and Scott Brown are better right-midfielders than Paul Caddis is.

For these reasons I don't think Paul Caddis should be in the first team unless there is an injury crisis.

 

Hes not a good enough defender to make it here at RB and theres too much competition on the wings.

Hes not doing himself any favours staying here. I thought he had said that he'd be off in Jan if he wasn't a reg? Could do some damage in the Championship but he isn't getting any younger.

 

heard from (yes a reliable source, no joke) that he is away to swindon or leeds.

 

Hope he goes tbh. Him and the likes of Misun, Mizuno, McGowan and all the other ones taking in their wages for doing eff all.

 

Thats a bit harsh. We haven't got the chance to see much of Misun yet. Mizuno and McGowan can go though. McGowan is a good finisher but he looks inconsistant.

 

never been overly impressed by him, far too lightweight as well imo for a rb.

 

wont get near the starting line up with hinkel there, and pick mark wilson before him, didnt really impress with his loan at united last year either probably time to go

 

mark wilson is miles better than him or hinkel

 

Never going to make the grade here.

 

good idea. In fact why don't we just scrap our whole youth academy set-up and not bring any talent through

Ill agree with you on Mizuno - he isn't going to make it but McGowan, Misun and Caddis are all talented players who have cost very little to bring through and are on low wages. All 3 of them are pushing to be in the first team and have played a few games. (Misun would have played quite a bit this season if it wasn't for his cruciate injury)

If we are looking at people not pulling their weight to get off the wage bill many first team players deserve to go ahead of any youngsters

 

Hmm squad player at best, it only seems to be the fans who have ranted and raved about him over the past what 3? 4? seasons, if he were only as good as some of the folk on here give him credit for then he would be a first choice fullback.

I wouldn't even give it a second thought it he left Celtic in the summer.