Brown or Thomson?

me and my mates were chatting and he is a hibs fan and said that celtic bought the wrong hibee...?

thoughts?

 

They are both *

 

X2^

We should have off loaded brown when we had the chance . i honestly think hes a tool ,

 

brown is better i think and not just cause hes playing for celtic

 

i think Thompson is slightly better

 

Thomson, though he's a cheating wee rat so suits the Huns.

 

Thomson is suited to the Huns setup while Brown ain't to us,we are a better team when he's not in it

 

Both very good players when fit and on form. Thompson has probably showed his quality more. I think Broony is a more difficult player to find a role. Broony showed on Saturday that he has a lot of skill. We tend to forget he is very good at spinning and dropping the shoulder if you can get him into less deep positions and free to attack. I quite like the idea of Broony as a (narrow) wide right player. He has played some great games there for Scotland. A lot of his best qualities are wasted when he is tied to a CM role that means he has to be very sparing about when he attacks. I think a good model for Broony would be Graveson before he went mad. He was a magnificent all action player who looked best in a role with freedom.

 

Thomson is better and he is also a tim. Thomson suits us and Brown suits them.

 

You cannot be a tim and play for rangers.

Some people might find that controversial but thats how i feel

 

A think Thomson shades it hard for me to say lol Celtic got ripped off with Brown 4.4m is a joke he's good but not that good, if he is then he's not shown it, i hope he would prove me wrong lol

 

rather have brown dont see much in thomson

 

Neither, both over rated. The money spent on Mr Brown is unjustifiable. We could have purchased a more intelligent footballer for the reputed 4.4 million.

 

Said when they were both at Hibs that Thomson was better. He still is. Really wish we had got him, Brown is rotten.

 

Brown's better going forward and Thomson's better at breaking up attacks in the middle.

 

none of them are that good.over hyped as usual.the minute a scottish guy starts to get a game in the spl he gets made out to be better than he really is.

 

Brown's the better player. Thomson can't get a game for Scotland & rangers.

 

He's in the Rangers team every week, when fit. And he'll be in the Scotland team also. He was injured for a long time, hence why he wasn't playing for either for a good while there.

 

Thomson

 

both overrated iv yet to be overly impressed with either since their moves from hibs, with the exception of browns one decent season. thompson seems to get good reviews for doing what as far as i can see is a poor impression of the job mcelbows already does for them.