Hertha Want Hinkel

£5million and we're in business
You struggle to name 6 better right backs in Britain atm

 

This could be a chance for caddis keep telling you all he is class trust me

 

and who would we replace him with for 2,5 mill?

 

"....It’s understood Wojtowicz was impressed by Hinkel’s attacking form in the derby game but was unable to make a definite decision due to Rangers’ failure to to test him in a defensive sense."

He's worth more than £2.5m! In any case, this article is pish! Who would decide on a player on the basis of one game?

 

add an extra million to that and its a deal!

 

2.5 is decent enough i reckon!
he's an average defender but think caddis could turn out to be a great little player!

 

arguement that we shouldnt let him go for £2.5m but we would NOT IN A MILLION YEARS get £4-£5m for him. We didn't even need to pay that for him and he was coming from Sevilla...not the spl!!

 

Its exactly how it works. He is in form in the SPL. I can't remember the last time he played for Germany and he amdits himself he is unlikely to got to the world cup this year.

Not a chance we will get more than £3m imo

 

Really worried about this, Hinkel is one of our most consistent players and has the most assists in the SPL this season(?)(most assists at celtic anyway). Unfortunately he may want to go because we all know he's desperate to play for Germany at the world cup German international - £5m please

@Roslea - just over a year ago

 

Yeah hes a good player, i would rather he was a top class defender rather than assists though.

He is unlikely to go to WC. We wont get £5m for him

 

£5million for hinkel are you on drugs.take the 2.5million from hertha and give caddis a chance

 

Look.

We don't have to sell him, so why would we? Unless we've got a ready made replacement sitting waiting to step in, he's going nowhere. Not for that sort of money. We don't have a replacement, yet. Wilson isn't good enough and I think he'll go in Jan. Caddis seems to be getting pushed in to a RM position, which is fine. So at the moment, we don't have a replacement. If we still had Doumbe, I'd take the £2.5m. Not now though.

£2.5m? We'd never get the same quality. It's same reason we want top top dollar for McGeady, it's going to take atleast £10m to replace the likes of McGeady, even then I doubt you'd get anyone willing to come to the SPL in the same sort of class.

 

You won't get £5M for Hinkel IMO. And that is because of his age, and the fact that he is not so hot in defence.

There are plenty of good right backs about as well. Johnson, Sagna, Corluka, Richards, Bosingwa, Hutton, Alves, Ramos, Oddo Maicon or Lahm .

£.2.5 M is about right I feel.We could replace him easily.

 

With?

those you mentioned, other than Corluka, Lahm, Oddo (age) and Hutton are all £20m+

 

Most right backs in the epl are as good as Hinkel.

If he was that good there would be clubs lining up to buy him. simples.