What is your overall ratings of all our main players out of ten ?

How are you rating Agathe 6, who hasnt played a game ALL season and then say its too earlyto rate Keane when Keane has played a full 90 minutes? I just cant understand this logic.

Also I'd be reserving 10/10 for World Class, World Cup winning, Ronaldinho type performances. I didnt any of that this season from any Celtic player or anything close. But that's just the way im rating the players

 

Fair point, im just rating Agathe average as I have seen him previous seasons so i'm not puting his rating above or below average. I didn't rate Keane as he has only played in a hoops top once.
Exactly why I didn't use any 10's, thats too high, if Petrov and Naka are 10's, whats Ronaldinho, Rooney etc?

 

exactly

 

Boruc - 8
Marshall - 7
Agathe - 8
Telfer - 5
McManus - 7
Balde - 6
Du Wei - ?
Virgo - ?
Varga - 7
Camara - 5
Wallace - 6
Nakamura - 9
Maloney - 8
Petrov - 9
Pearson - 7
Thompson - 6
Lennon - 7
Keano - ?
Zurawski - 8
Hartson - 8
Beattie - 8
McGlinchy - ?
McGeady - 8

 

for * sake he doesnt give up

 

1. Boruc 9
2. Telfer 4
3. Camara 4 Wallace 3
4. Mc Manus 5
5. Balde 7 Du Wei ? Virgo ? Varga ?
6. Petrov 9
7. Lennon 7
8. Nakamura 9 Pearson 6
9. Zurawski 7 Beattie 6
10. Hartson 7
11. Maloney 7 McGeady 6 Thompson 5



I know Agathe hasn't really played but based on past seasons I put him as a 7.

 

My ratings of all our first team regulars are -


Boruc - 9
Marshall - 6
Agathe - 6
Telfer - 7
McManus - 8
Balde - 7
Du Wei - (Too early to judge)
Virgo - 6
Varga - who cares as long as he leaves
Camara - 6.5
Wallace - 6.5
Nakamura - 8.5
Mcgeady - 8
Maloney - 8.5
Petrov - 10
Pearson - 7
Thompson - 6
Lennon - 8
Keano - (Too early to judge)
Zurawski - (Too early to judge)
Hartson - 7.5
Beattie - 8
McGlinchy - (Too early to judge)

 

Boruc - 11 best signing
Marshall - 7
Agathe - 7
Telfer - 6
McManus - 8
Balde - 8
Du Wei - needs another chance
Virgo - 7
Varga - 6
Camara - 7
Wallace - 7
Nakamura - 9
Maloney - 9
Petrov - 10
Pearson - 7
Thompson - 6
Lennon - 8
Keano - can't say
Zurawski - 8
Hartson - 7
Beattie - 9

 

Boruc - 7 or 8. Take of the green glasses people
Marshall - 7(not seen much of him thou lately)
Agathe - 5
Telfer - 5
McManus - 7
Balde - 6
Du Wei - not seen enough
Virgo - 6
Varga - 6
Camara - 6
Wallace - 6
Nakamura - 8
Maloney - 7
Petrov - 9
McGeady- 7
Pearson - 7
Thompson - 7
Lennon - 6 (over rated)
Keano - not seen enough
Zurawski -8
Hartson - 8 or 9 (gets the goals)
Beattie - 8

 

why is people giving keane good ratings ????? hes played one game and i didnt even hear his name expect for when the commentary where saying this is roy keanes debut ffs wise up

 

Boruc - 9
Marshall - 6
Agathe - cant judge
Telfer - 6
McManus - 8
Balde - 6
Du Wei - cant judge
Virgo - cant judge
Varga - 5
Camara - 7
Wallace - 6
Nakamura - 9
Maloney - 9
Petrov - 9
Pearson - 7
Thompson - 5
Lennon - 7
Keano - cant judge
Zurawski - cant judge
Hartson - 8
Beattie - 8
McGlinchy - cant judge

 

Boruc - 9
Marshall - 6
Agathe ?
Telfer - 5
McManus - 7
Balde - 6
Du Wei - ?
Virgo - 5
Varga - 5
Camara - 6
Wallace - 3
Nakamura - 9
Maloney - 9
Petrov - 9
Pearson - 6
Thompson - 6
Lennon - 7
Keano - ?
Zurawski - 7
Hartson - 7
Beattie - 7

 

boruc-9
marshall?
telfer-6
agathe?
mcmanus-7
bobo-7
du wei-?
virgo-?
varga-?
camara-7
wallace-5
naka-9
petrov-9
maloney-9
pearson-7
thommo-7
lennon-8
keano-?
magic-8
hartson-7
beattie-7
mc geady-8

 

Boruc - 9
Marshall -?
Agathe - ?
Telfer -6
McManus - 7
Balde - 7
Du Wei - ?
Virgo - ?
Varga - ?
Camara - 6
Wallace - 6
Nakamura - 9
Maloney - 8
Petrov - 9
Pearson - 6
Thompson - 5
Lennon - 7
Keano - ?
Zurawski - 8
Hartson - 8
Beattie - 7
McGeady - 8

by the way im taking these ratings as this season so far,thats why i havent rated marshall agathe etc.

 

the man played 1 game m8.