Your vote on who should be manager

I'd take anyone from that list, i'm just so happy Ginger has finally got the hint.:icon_mrgreen:

 

I went with Mowbray, realistically the best option.

What is it with Billic! Have I missed something! He hasnt manged a club yet!

 

Bruce

 

I'd choose Wenger - he really has the Celtic spirit.

So does Guardiola, but his heart is in Catalunya.

OK, OK, I realise neither of those is realistic, but neither is Davie Moyes or Bilic.

Out of the list above:

Owen Coyle : Has done exceptionally well at Burnley, in both the league and the cup, and could be a future star. Would do for me.
Tony Mowbray : Would have us playing some nice football, but not convinced he'd have us winning trophies.
Mark McGhee : Have a lot of time for the guy, he would love the job, but I'm not convinced he has the track record.
Craig Levine : I know Tannadice is a far cry from Paradise, but I'm not sure he is committed to the Celtic style of play.
Alan Curbishley : Very interesting option. He certainly has the pedigree - achieved amazing things with Charlton, has a great eye for a player, and a long track record of achievement with limited funds (which is what we have). His only other job? Saving West Ham from almost certain relegation.
Paul Lambert : Doesn't have the track record.
Neil Lennon : Doesn't have the track record, and I don't think he has the necessary guile to be a top manager.
Roy Keane : Would sooner see George Bush as Celtic manager.
David Moyes : Would have him in a moment, but he's currently in charge of the 5th team in the world's wealthiest league, and getting paid 3 million a year for the privilege. His next employer will probably be Man U.

Ruling out Moyes, my preferred options would be:
Curbishley, who is the best manager on the list by a margin.
Coyle, who I think has the most potential, and who is also a Celtic fan.

 

intresting, no one voted McGhee

 

Why? Question was asked who we'd like to see, and yes my 1st choice is Bilic....

 

Voted for Owen Coyle but would be amazing if we got David Moyes. To be totally honest i don't expect us to get either of them. Big Tony Mowbray looks the favorite & i'll give him my backing if he steps up.

 

Coyle is the current favourite, around 2/1 on the exchange.

Mowbray about 4/1 - and the 3rd favourite is David O'Leary, who doesn't figure in the poll.

 

seriously someone edit the spelling on this list

 

Moyes.

 

would love to see us aproach hiddink.
from the list, mcgee for the simple reason he knows the scottish game ,and has a feeling for the club but, been gave the kiss of death cauz wgs is backing him so fans are no backing mcgee now.

 

apart from Moyes, the rest are a step down in CV terms from WGS. Backwards step to get a manager who has no European experience and less successful EPL experience than WGS had. If the board are looking at Championship/yo-yo fodder like Coyle, Mowbray, McGhee, Grant etc ghod help us. Of the cheapies, Levein impresses me most and can clearly do a good SPL job which will be the priority (Europe IMO is never priority when you are not champs.

 

BTW, its pure idiocy the way the list is full of ex-Celts. That is no way to pick a list of options. Jock Stein wouldnt have got a sniff in that baised (illegal?) employment policy.

 

Now that is a good shout by the way.

 

mogga for me :icon_mrgreen:

 

Only one for me is Moyes- he is the only one thats a bit proven, Mogga !!, even the WGS haters would admit that he has a worse reecord trying to keep an EPL alive, so not for me

 

For gimmick purposes, I voted for Lennon.

But, in all seriousness the choice is David Moyes.

 

I would go for Owen Coyle just for the fact that he would be able to teach our strikers how to score.

 

Bilic for me

 

i wouldnt mind bilic either or moyes /coyle EXCLUSIVE: Croatia coach Bilic eyes Parkhead post but Coyle is Celtic's first choice | Mail Online