SPFL Hibs V Celtic Saturday February 22nd kick off 12:30 Premier sports 2

Any pics of the ball being out of play for the chopped of goal?

 

Mclean and Muir 2015 Scottish cup semi final pre match celtic would have played Falkirk in the final he's a *

 

Hibs are 13 unbeaten. Since we last played.

 

Just saw on premier sports and VAR had said this is the view we used, it is inconclusive. Could have been out but no way you can say for certain.

 

Exactly it, they're always likely to * the bed but nothing more.

 

Apologies, carry on boss

 

Alan Muir last season against Killie, denied celtic 95th min penalty and also a blatant red card on Taylor

 

Again...Its got nothing to do with us loosing.....Thought we were absolute * most of the game....2nd half a bit better.

But that call actually angers me....even if we scored it and hibs went on to win the game doesnt bother me.....The fact it was chopped off with no conclusive evidence and going against a linesmans call needs to be looked at by our club.

How many * times do these things go against us? Is it going to take us finishing second and loosing 50 million for CL before its stated?


WE * PAY FOR THIS....

 

I think it's a little naive to say that the refs were responsible for us losing today, but also that they didn't play a part in it... We can be bad and so can they, both independently or simultaneously...

In my own opinion the refs gave far more in favour of Hibs in terms of what they pulled or didn't than they did for us. I also think that we were exceptionally poor for the first half, only decent in the second, and yet still when it came to it we should have gotten a draw...

We came off the back of a very tough match midweek, where we suffered a demoralising late shock - we should have been playing tomorrow if you ask me!, against a rested team with a good form at home. We were a shadow of our capability, and I'd expect we won't play like that again this season... We had a questionable late goal disallowed, on top of 2 more suckerpunch early/late goals from the first half... We dropped points, it happens, it's not critical or fatal... We move on!

 

Missed the second half. What's the deal with the disallowed goal? Was it over the line?

 

Mad one that disallowed goal. Held off celebrating cos I thought it was out. Then went mental when it was given. Then reluctantly accepted it looked out.

But watching Brendan and Lenny after it talking about it being 'inconclusive' and 'having a guess at it', that's exactly right. There's no way they can prove it's out so it should stand.

* rat bag * AGAIN.

 

Conclusive evidence of the ball being out?

 

Need better than a camera angled at it from 50 yards away to be sure... But it does look like it's more out than in, so it's not like we're getting absolutely rode on it... But the rules are clear - decisions stand unless they can be categorically deemed incorrect! I'm not seeing the certainty there... We're going into weird territory with VAR overruling linesmen and refs on such contentious decisions if they don't have the proper tools to make the assessments

 

If that’s the angle VAR used we should be going all guns blazing at the *, that is not a conclusive angle it needs to be clear and obvious.

 

And also not clear from that angle either.

 

In ANY instances where VAR are being used there MUST be cameras on both ends of each and every line to allow the assessment of in or out... That's not rocket science, it's simple, common sense to give them the essential tools of the job... Otherwise it's like asking a joiner to use an old brick from the site to knock in nails... Technically possible, but completely unacceptable work practice...

 

How can they make that decision based on that camera angle.

Isn't the rule, if unsure or inconclusive then doesn't the on field decision stand? And according to that clip the goal was given by McLean.