Stephen Welsh

He's so poor..

His passing all day was beyond brutal..

 

Surely can't play again. Absolutely rotten.

 

Every time he plays we concede every time he plays our defense look dodgy i just dont think he is any where good enough for us

 

Been saying it for ages that he isn’t good enough and that goes for being backup. He’s only here for the home grown quota.

 

If he wasn’t Scottish he would have been punted ages ago.

I think injuries ruined him tbh. There was potential there at one point.

 

He’s not even Aberdeen or Hibs standard. The guy is dross.

 

Time to call it a day with the Welsh experiment.


I get that he's likely more for a quota at this stage, but there is zero way he should be ahead of Nawrocki and at this stage I'd rather the quota slot given to another youth.

I gave him a break for a long time as he really didn't make a debut/impact til I think he was 20/21
Is now 24 and will be 25 later in this season. He plays like he's still making his first debut most times.

He looks okay to be fair, but he's never developing. Best he moves on for even his own sake now.

Give the slot to the next youth product, preferably one that's not missed about 3 years of development because we have a massive issue between ages of 18 and getting a fair crack at the first team (if ever).

Promote the next 17/18 year old now and see what they can do.

Sent from my M2012K11AG using Tapatalk

 

Rotten.

 

Feel bad for him as he's played well for us before, but he doesn't look good enough even as a backup now.

 

Terrible today and the only surprise is he didn’t go off injured . Nawrocki should surely be ahead of him in future, if he isn’t he needs punted as obviously not rated .

 

*.

 

Am in the minority but think he has a place in the squad. He's shown before he can put in a decent performance, just never consistently. Emergency backup I'd cal him.

 

Yes, I think you're in the minority m8

 

Terminate his conteact

Skickat från min SM-F926B via Tapatalk

 

His passing and positioning today were dreadful. I can't remember anything he did well today even when we did up our game

 

No for the first time, nor the last.

 

It's always going to be hard for any player coming into the team and being part of a whole new back 4. Maybe that today is why players should be introduced 1 at a time into a settled team but it's probably unfair but I've never seen anything in Welsh to think he can get better or even be a decent back up..there's no way this guy is better than nawrocki and if he's on a par then both need to be sold .

 

That's just not true..

 

Every time he plays he gets worse. Essentially sat on bench for the last 4 years and it shows, not a good defender and just not a good footballer. Has only been kept because he’s Scottish for the homegrown quota.