'Honest' mistakes 24/25

The one on McGregor in the second half for me was for sure a PK.

 

First one on Maeda was a pen. As was the challenge on Johnston at Easter Road the other week right before half time. The other two shouts today weren’t pens I don’t think.

 

The change probably being if Celtic get penalty claims don't give them and leave them to VAR.

I feel like we've had about 6/7 penalty claims 3/4 could easily have been given in the 3 League games so far and we've had heehaw.

 

Would have been soft penalties tbh, but same as usual wait and see if it's consistent, will other teams get those decisions against us, will the huns get away with worse etc..

 

Agreed

 

Red Card for the Raised Arms vs AJ?

Would like to see the So called Offside moment with a view from straight on.

 

Pulling play back twice when we had the ball in decent positions for free kicks to us was mental. We’re deemed free kicks initially but when we broke away they were?

Just saw the offside pic without the lines as they show * all anyway. Looked on to me.

 

Don’t think Kuhn was offside, level at worst

 

Thought the offside rule was changing to benefit the attacker more ? Is that next season ?

 

The offside was on.
Take the var lines off, you can follow the line of the grass cut, he's onside

That's the second time this season, they've called ours offside due to an arm (not even sure his arm was off in this one), when arms can't be used for offside - as per a Hun goal earlier as well.


Absolutely cheating *.

The club should call that out, publicly ask the * to confirm or deny the offside rule regarding the arm, then present them with either of the alternative evidence which clearly shows they don't apply it consistently

Sent from my M2012K11AG using Tapatalk

 

Whereas it just benefits the one team just now. Serious though, no matter what the plans are to change it we all know it will always be handled dishonestly by our crooked officials

 

Souttar handball is a stonewaller too, just saw a vid of it l. Engels also wiped out from behind a second after.

Should be calling these decisions out when we win, but we won’t for some reason.

 

Can only find thefa link to this:
https://www.thefa.com/football-rule... player is in an,and the second-last opponent

But the arm can't be used for offside.
Scottish rules tend to just copy and paste the English as well anyway and I'm sure they've already said it won't count the arms, but here we are with the two lines indicating to the outside part of each players arm - which shouldn't be used.

Cheating *.

Sent from my M2012K11AG using Tapatalk

 

Dodgy tarts, let's get this clarified

 

If you zoom right in look at the Huns shoulder where they start the line down compared to khuns,

Sent from my 21121210G using Tapatalk

 

A bloke on you tube said why do they always show our VAR at an angle compared to the EPL that show it straight

 

Oh yeah, good old mobile phones... rangers shoulder is definitely further forward... Needs calling out.

 

I have no idea whether it was on or off, I genuinely can't tell from that angle; but hopefully this puts to bed this nonsense about these decisions being objective, just because a few lines are dropped from shoulders. When the width on the image of the shoulders is greater than the size on the image of the claimed offside, how can the decision of where to draw the line be anything other than subjective? It's not like our shoulders come with a sharp bend you can use.