Idah vs Miovski

If both players were to be available for around the same amount of money who would you rather we signed?

 

Idah

 

Send Oh on loan..

And sign both.

 

Neither

 

Neither if we have any interest in at least getting to the next round in even the europa.

 

miovski scored 4 in their 7 european fixtures this season. Think he has potential to go up a level at a bigger club, also seems like he turns up in the big games.

This is also assuming we still have kyogo who I assume would be our starting striker.

 

Idah has done a job but I'd rather have Miovski. Then Idah would be too expensive for a 3rd choice striker so go and get someone else too.

 

Neither, both okay but not good enough. We should be aiming higher

 

Miovski has turned up for the games against us and Rangers. He has caused both teams real trouble.

The quality of his play and finishing suggests he will go much higher than Aberdeen.

 

Idah

 

Whoever is cheaper and spend big bucks on a quality striker.

 

People will rage at me... but honestly if we could sign these two for a combined total of under £15mill I would 100% sign both without hesitation.

And as much as personally think Oh does have something about him because you don't get the number of goals he has in so few minutes without at least having a hint of talent, I'd sadly let him leave for whatever offer is put on the table.

 

I haven’t watched Miovski enough to really comment but can’t help but feel this debate has come to light because of what we saw yesterday, more than anything else. The responses could be much different in a couple of weeks.

When it comes to Idah, I don’t think he’ll ever be a natural finisher, but it’s plain to see he has some great attributes and having only just turned 23 I can see him only getting better. I’d still be pretty happy if we spent 5/6 million on him.

 

We should be aiming higher, as others have stated.

I like Idah, happy to see him doing well, but Miovski is a much better player.

 

I like idah but been impressed with miovski anytime I’ve seen him. Seems very well round and has all the attributes. Also very good goal return this season in a struggling Aberdeen team

 

I've been a big Miovski fan since I first saw him. Really like him. He is a great out ball, he can create something out of nothing, and he manages to score a bundle playing for a poor Aberdeen side. I was desperately hoping we would sign him in January and would be happy if we signed him in the summer.

Idah, I feel has done a decent shift. He offers a good alternative from the bench and was a wise loan signing. But I've not really seen much from him to suggest that he would be worth signing on a permanent deal.

 

Yup

 

Miovski has scored 24 goals for Aberdeen this season, I don't think Idah could do that.

100% Miovski for me at the same price. Although I'm not sure either are the answer to seriously challenge Kyogo and push us on

 

First priority should be getting the system and players to play to Kyogo's strengths since he's miles clear of both when he has support (and is in form which has hasn't been for parts of this season). Failing that I'd take Miovski over Idah, I like the dirty work Idah can do but Miovski is a natural goalscorer and Idah is far from that. I do think a club like ours should have three strikers as options though so maybe getting both for next season is feasible?