Mafia 67 - Rockstars At War

Mafia candidates.

Saul Goodman
Slaw
Sean Daleer
Seán Mac D
Cena
JC Anton

Dazza feels Town.

There's a doctor among that lot as well as a SK and at least 1 scum possibly 2 .

We need to focus on one person.

 

Feel pretty certain Daz is town. Pennywise definitely not mafia. Daleer didn’t read as scum to me. Was Cenas name cleared at all or is he still fair game? Sean Mac and Saul seem most likely scum to me.

 

Nice.

Claim more than half might be mafia then say we need to focus on one

That's not confusing at all.

 

Seán Mac D - will wait to see what he's saying today
JC Anton - Missed Jim and Slippy lynch, seemed to be diverting attention when I called out Jims character

Saul Goodman - same character band as Jim, potentially they came up with fake claims and he said RATM would be a good band to claim, was at pains to empathise Minty likes RATM when he claimed.

Slaw - seems to be actively looking at least

Sean Daleer - early on Slippy
Cena - voted at important time on slippy

 

SK/survivor is a bit of a spanner in the works obviously as that could still be Penny or any of the guys who pushed a Mafia lynch

 

I’m really still not convinced there is a SK

 

Sorry lads, I’ve had a busy couple of days, but finished work now for the weekend. I’ve only really skimmed the thread and seen my name being mentioned by people but haven’t seen one logical reason, all I’ve seen is people taking asvantage of the fact I was quiet for two days. Easy to do for the remaining scum I suppose.

I will be having a proper read of the thread at some point this evening and will give my thoughts on who I think remaining scum are then.

 

Why would I want us to claim members from the same band if I was scum?

What do you mean at pains? I just figured it was worth mentioning because I didn’t know the character myself and it was at a point where everyone was working out what was meant by them.

 

I am pretty confident Jim claimed he had a character from the same band to make me look suspicious if/when he flipped.

It’s the only reason I can think he claimed it.

 

Aye, who knows whats going on with the SK role but aye it would be unusual to combine commuter with SK as logic would suggest you'd need to be in Town to kill.. often SK is given an extra leg up tho as its difficult to win.

 

I didn't miss Slippy's lynch.. and I've explained a couple of times on Day1, I didn't want scum splitting the vote.

 

Maybe you didn't necessarily want it, maybe you were floating some options for claims in the chat and Jim made a rookie mistake

I saw your explanation and it is viable, however imo it still leaves you with less town cred than others who were on to Slippy eg Daleer and Cena

 

Vote Sean Mac

Until we get some info. If we do.

 

In the absence of concrete info and with the deadline tonight I'm going to Vote Pennywise again

 

*, right at the same time

 

Daz
Bob
Sean mac
JC
Pennywise
Daleer

that’s the train that lynched Spring. Definitely at least 1 or 2 scum in there. We know it’s probably not Daz or Bob. We need to get a lynch today, don’t think it’s wise to miss another lynch like the other day and give up a free kill

 

This wasn’t Jim’s first game of Mafia, he’s played before on a previous account.

 

Daleer suss as well

 

I thought Bob got a not guilty on Pennywise?

 

I’m the most suspicious of Saul out of everyone here I feel. Been trying to show my workings for that the last couple of days but nobody seems to agree. But even I would say that the character thing, if anything, is a mark in favour of Saul being town. Would be stupid for scum to co-ordinate a fake claim with band mates, I don’t get it.