Honest Mistakes Thread 2016/17 onwards.

He’s dived before the contact is made when that happens they should be rightly booked if they want the pen then take the contact


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

I don’t think the hand ball is in the box


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Clancy got the original decision bang on… the problem is when u look at a still, it does look like it’s a pen. It’s a * farce. It’s becoming an absolute farce. The common denominator is the incompetent refs, get them to *

 

Think there's enough video evidence over the last 5 weeks to send to the SFA to explain these decisions and what action will they take on these refs as there need to be a punishment for these shocking decisions .
The club should put enough pressure on these * that a second refs strike kicks in and foreign refs are brought in but we can't sit and say nothing as it will get worse if we do nothing.

 

Not handball.. not even in the box.. we are up against it beyond words

 

Went to a VAR check for infringement and came back saying (on bbc text saying Check over...
Hearts 0-0 Livingston

No penalty.

Andrew Shinnie's arms were down by his side and he was inches from the ball.

Nothing he could have done, but the way the handball law is being interpreted it wouldn't have been a huge shock if he'd been penalised.)

Sounds like a clear hit the arm but was down and no time to react, sound sounds pretty similar

 

It wasn’t even a shot on goal the Ross county boy had his back to goal it’s an absolute farcical decision. Where in that was denying a goal scoring opportunity? Compare that to the hearts one against the HUNS

 

* Munro knew what he was doing chose not to go to the monitor if he does and doesn’t give the pen the onus is on him who was var ref ? McLean


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

I've been watching Celtic for 60 odd years Paddy and, as you can imagine, I've seen some dreadful refereeing in that time. We all knew that there were dyed in the wool huns such as Tiny Wharton, McCurry, Davidson etc. who gave us sweet * all and who then found themselves gigs on the after dinner guest speaker circuit (where they openly admitted to giving us * all) right to the modern day Lanarkshire band of (masonic) cheating hun * such as Beaton and Madhun etc. who have continued the trend. However, like yourself Paddy, I've been alarmed at what we have all witnessed over the last few months and I believe that the introduction of VAR has taken the levels of cheating to a whole new level. The majority of dodgy decisions have been against our team and/or favour those teams playing us and, not surprisingly, only one team has truly benefitted from VAR's introduction and that's been the huns. Our game is corrupt and our club need to tackle it head on or we will, sooner or later, suffer the consequences despite our teams character to never stop. I think todays shambolic refereeing display should be the catalyse for our club to finally tackle the SFA head on and demand change to the refereeing system and maybe it should begin with ensuring that referees with leanings towards the huns should be prevented from officiating in either our games or theirs.

 

Looking for the one where the keeper put it down then picked it up so the ref gave the keeper a free kick. I see sportscene didn’t show it..

 

Only one team haven’t conceded a penalty since var… I’ll let you guess who

 

Infuriates me he never went to the monitor


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Didn't show the one O'Riley(?) won the ball from the RC player and put us through one on one and they pulled it back for a free kick either. Unreal how they are getting away with this. Needs to go beyond the huns that run our game.

 

Did he go to monitor I remember seeing him touching his ear and going with what’s said in his ear


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

It's just never a penalty..

Take away the fact he couldn't do anything about it and was right next to him.....we actually had the ball and the players nipped in and flicked it up off a mix of his hand and hip..

The wee orange * couldn't give it quick enough. I actually didn't realise for a second that he'd given a penalty. Then for that other orange * Euan Anderson in the minority room to say nothing and give it the ok..

Just cheating *..

 

11 teams in the League have conceded penalt(y/ies)

 

It was Clancy I think that went to monitor Munro chose to give the pen right away even though he didn’t see it county player wasin front t of him yet blew for it and let guy in var room confirm chose not to go to the monitor