[Mafia] South Park Mafia 55 - Bigger, Longer & Uncut!

Because a gif of a Jew I put up was apparently him.

From as soon as we all character-claimed I’ve been consistent in saying he’s just a Jew with no name.

 

Not adamant, I think we should be finding the SK first.

No harm in working through patterns from the rest of the game in the time-being though.

 

@Idioteque that’s me on Monday correcting @Seán Mac D who wrote me down as ‘Gerald’.

 

Do we even know there is an SK?

You seem fairly certain of that.

 

Aye, when I compiled the list I put Gerald as anyone who watches South Park will know him as that but I can see why Minty might've said Jew to Aidan as a joke.

 

There's deffo another killing role away from Mafia, thats a certainty due to write ups, think Sk fits the bill. @Jeremie Frimpong has mentioned he thinks it's aliens numerous times, personally dont agree. Could be 2 mafia factions but again thats highly highly unlikely.

 

JC Anton - VT with 1 x hit blunt
Keano - Town Jailkeeper
Dazza - Town Watcher
Valhalla - Town Doctor
Cena - Town Miller
Summer Time - Town Cop
Deebo - Mafia Strong(wo)man
Marie - Town Bike
CookieMonster - Innocent Townie


Can anyone remember the characters that have died ?

Deebos character matches his role for sure.
maire character seemed to match her role. Can’t remember the others
summer maybe was the cop, was the * some sort of cop in the show ?

I honestly think a lot of roles match the character.

Sean D and Oba match their roles as they both run a weed farm in the show so can see why they would be able to hit blunts

 

Has there ever been a game with no SK?

The write ups certainly seem to suggest a SK, as some deaths are attributed to groups and others a lone individual has killed them.

 

[My thoughts:

Twisty - Scum. Killed town day 1, avoided explaining his role, voted for everyone except the mafia lynch, admitted to being mafia and killing Marie and then said it was all a joke. Full of *.

Idio - Definitely lying about something. Had the opportunity to reveal something about Jeremie but when it came back as town cred he tried to explain it away, and abruptly flipped to Aidan based on a character description which was only half-true.

Jeremie - Lean scum. Voting all over the place but he was granted town cred, assuming Idio is telling the truth. His claim is very sketchy though.

Aidan - Lean town. Character doesn't line up as well, but he did vote for scum and tried to protect V when it seemed clear V would protect Marie.

Sean Mac D - Probably town. Role makes sense but can't confirm without wasting a town lynch. Similar danger to Jeremie

V - Likely town. Claim lines up with Marie's actions, but he slipped not protecting her. Genuine mistake could be true.

Daleer - Town. His use of the blunt makes sense as it was going to run out, and it's the same condition that Anton had.]

 

so the serial killer was wearing a suit this kill.

You!" said Cookie.

"Yes me.“



​

 

Obaf, Sean and V or Aidan = scum


Or *.

 

almost like he knew him. His dad perhaps ?

 

What do you think @Aidan O’Shea ?

 

I refer both Idio and yourself to Minty’s own point that characters descriptions (and by extension write-ups) are a stupid thing to base a vote on.

 

that’s the first serial kill. Just so we can review

 

hows it stupid when Deebo was strong wo(man) and he role was strong man?

 

[Honestly mate, for both of these...man in a suit, black car, bricks on the feet. Those are all mafia things.]

 

Also we have used write ups in all our games to help draw conclusions

 

When is deadline? Tomorrow at 11pm?

 

this is from the same night as Wendy’s death. Surely wasn’t 2 mafia kills in one night. He says a different black car