Christie vs Rogic

Who is your first choice?

For me it is Christie. Quicker, more energetic. The team seem so much more fluid with Christie.

Think he is set for a huge huge season. Very excited to see this bhoys career progress!

 

Unpopular opinion, I've never been that big a fan of Rogic... It feels like he turns up only 3/4 games a season - being honest, I'd sell him.

I'm going for Christie here for similar reasons the op mentioned.

 

Yup totally agree! Although he is a big game player, just can’t rely on him most of the season (most due to injuries tbf)

 

Pressed Rogic by accident. I do think Rogic is technically better than Christie and can do things Christie can't.
But Christie has an insane work rate and can actually manage to play 90 mins, without being injured 24/7 so has to be him.

 

Will need them both this season hopefully.Voted Christie as hes most in form right now,I know Rogic is injured but he had a poor last season.Think he'll be more suited to Lennons faster more direct football rather than BRs style.

 

I think people’s forgotten how good Rogic is because of last season.

 

Rogic for me. Capable of a magic moment nobody else in our current squad can provide.

 

Rogic to me is our Le Tissier, and Christie our Scholes...

Tommy contributes at times, but most of the time we carry him. Christie is shaping up to be the engine of the team for years. Between the injuries and the constant call ups for oz, I don't see there's really a contest here

 

Really depends on how we’re going to play and the opposition.

Rogic at his best is outstanding, but those sort of performances are fairly few and far between. Christie appears to be more consistent and gives us more tactical flexibility with his ability to last 90 minutes and the defensive side to his game.

Right now the jersey is Christie’s to lose.

 

Christie all day long.

On the park for the full 90 minutes, running himself into the ground. Scoring goals, assisting goals, getting stuck in.

He simply offers more than Rogic. While Rogic has something special in his locker, Christie is the much more rounded player.

 

I picked Christie because right now he's looking far more consistently effective but Big Tam is by far the most capable of producing moments of world class genius.

Also he can shield a ball like no one I've ever seen which is great for drawing players out of position.

Christie is a Disrupter though and doesn't let players in position settle.

It's a great problem to have obviously. Our midfield is quite amazing.

 

Or play them both at times and move Christie back to give either Brown or McGregor a rest

McGregor Christie
Rogic

Was our best midfield last season

 

That's a good idea although Broony is by far part of our best midfield.

 

If rogic had Christie's energy...well let's be honest, he wouldn't be at celtic.

I love Tam, but he's becoming more of a sick note. There is something seriously wrong with him I think.

Christie had his face smashed in and still managed to get back before tam.

 

Christie for me for the all round closing down and general play. First line of defence and integral to attack.

That's not to detract from Tam who has a big role to play for us.

 

Rogic on his day is a sublime player he would be in my team everyday, I also think Christie is a brilliant player that seems to run on Duracell so it’s a really hard question.

 

Easily Rogic when he's at his best. Injury has just continually killed his momentum over the last couple of seasons though.