[Mafia] The Simpsons Mafia - DAY FIVE: TOWN WIN (Mafia 25)

Only claimed the Doctor role when you were given a gun..

The rest I’ve explained.

 

Your middle sentence - I have asked 3 times now - How would you know it was a townie you protected ? its a very simple question really

 

Do you have something you want to say or is this just to increase your post count ?

 

@JC Anton

It seems like an overpowered role, but I guess it might have been intended to counterbalance the Mafia Godfather role that @obafgkmlt discarded.

I’m not sure what to make of your claims, in all honesty, mate, but it is still bothering me that the only two players who have claimed powerful Town roles so far are the two players with the most Lynch votes.

 

You were in a wee huff, so I was comforting you.

 

jc , are you just the doctor and the reviver claim has just backed you into a corner ?

 

You’ve misunderstood what I’ve said.. the revive aspect would cast some doubt on me it’s the nature if such a role.. so the scum would leave me alone in the night(possibly) and then try and orchestrate a lynch during the Day.. being not targeted by the scum at night, would protect the Doctor aspect of the role..

Obviously that’s changed now you have given Slippy a gun.. you still haven’t answered really, why Slippy? Why now?

 

No I’m Doctor.. one shot Reviver..

Misunderstood the Reviver role, or wouldn’t have put it in jeopardy. It’s sometimes good for a Town power role to have doubt over them as they are less likely to be targeted at night.. that was my plan.. but the misunderstanding between me and @Keano88 was genuine..

 

@Tim-Time 1888

It is an awfully strange move, particularly after @Mr. Slippyfist shot a Town Cop in the last game. (@Keano88 has yet to confirm it.)

Would you care to explain your rationale?

 

How would scum know that you've revived anyone, if you do your reviving during the night stage?

 

Well, we will have a Doctor and my character is Dr. Hibbert.. unless this is counter claimed it should be believed.. or Town will lynch the Town Doctor..

 

Me in a huff naw but that coming from you is funny

 

In all fairness he explained it in his post where he gifted me, and has explained it once more after that.

Btw, come to think of it, Anton played a huge part in me shooting that cop in the last game, after I asked for advice and he told me to go for it, TT told me not to.

BOTH of them ended up being scum in some capacity. So did I right enough

 

They wouldn’t nobody would.. this as I say is the aspect I misunderstood..

 

No, I haven't misunderstood you at all. I have asked how you would know the townie you protected would be a townie at all ?

 

can i use one of your phrases jc , you have overthought this and that's where the confusion is .

that's fine for me , i believe you so wont vote .

i too had to query keano on my role as i thought it was just a straightforward one . but there are 2 conditions on it ive not seen before .

 

No, come on now; you were in a wee cream puff. Admit it.

 

No you said the aspect you misunderstood was that you could choose to revive a town power role that was killed someone with power to help town.
Then you found out you wouldn’t know what their faction or role would be as you had to choose your revive before their disclosure.

 

What I will say is it won’t be just me who has two aspects his role.. so what is @Tim-Time 1888 full role?

It’s a strange move giving you the Day Vig so early, don’t you think? If I had been unlucky a killed high profile Townies in previous and Tim and gifted the Day Vig to me, you would be all over that.. don’t you think?