[Mafia] The Simpsons Mafia - DAY FIVE: TOWN WIN (Mafia 25)

Lynching a Townie to bring him back doesn’t make any sense, Mafia lo just target them every night after it.

 

Oh you mean if I die...by a lynch?

What role would that be?

All the roles in this game when you look at the discards etc are Actual roles.. you’ve even found the role I’ve claimed.. would be an unsual claim, no?

 

Sorry what do you mean, I’m not advocating Lynching a Townie, I think Obaf is a SK..

 

Why you think that?

You’re using your role claim as a bit of a cop out though. ‘If they’re town I’ll revive them’ that wouldn’t really help in the long term though, the Mafia/SK’s/other factions will all just target them anyway...

 

Are you serious?

You honestly asking folk to be so naive as to not know that many folk have claimed ACTUAL available roles that wasn't their actual role?

Geez peace.

Oh, and it seems that your small role has grown a bit in stature as the day has gone on....

 

Sorry mate, I don’t know what you mean!?

My role is quite small, can bring someone back once.. that’s is!

 

Aye but the difference is if we get a lynch wrong and take out a useful role, I can bring them back..once..

It would look more suspicious imo, if they just surfaced again, alive..they would be a certainty to be lynched again.

 

@JC Anton you also helped me in the first couple of games and said don’t role reveal unless you’re on the verge of being lynched...

Not voting yet but you are all over the place. Why do you think OBAF is a SK?

 

mission nearly accomplished jc , all we are talking about is you , as scumbos lie low .

 

I'm trying very hard to see through what Anton desperately wants, because he clearly has some motive to his attention-seeking here. Either I'm lynched and he has some plan on what to do as his next step (possibly involving Che), or he keeps digging a hole and gets himself lynched because he's some kind of bomb. Either way, I don't trust a word he says.

 

Not all over the place mate... Obaf is either a SK or anazing Town role as his discard is so powerful.. that’s why I went for him as if wrong he can be revived..

In general I would say don’t early role claim, this Role we’ve never seen as a Town role I thought it was best to be upfront with it from the start, for the reasons mentioned..

Also scum will try and lynch me so it gives something to go on..

 

scum kill not lynch

 

Hmmmm.

Surely if there’s the slightest chance he’s got a powerful Town role we’d want that kept secret?

You’re at it.

Vote JC

 

The problem is even if you revive town, we can't trust that you're actually town. This same thing went down in the Celtic-themed game when I used my governor action to help town as "proof," but Minty didn't trust that anyway and lynched me. Course, I ended up being town there, but the doubt can't be eliminated no matter what you do. There is no "proof" unless you're the innocent child.

 

There’s no agenda.. only to out Scum..

If you have a Town role, I could bring you back simple.. but my feeling is SK and since you’re on..

Vote Obaf

 

That’s true.. being open about it is better tho.. rather than someone dying and just resurfacing..

 

I don’t think he is Town tho..

 

Scum will orchestrate the lynch..

 

You're orchestrating a lynch and nobody else

 

If I’m lying can someone enlighten me to what role, I could possibly have?