[Mafia] Mafia 18: Day 10 - Town Win!

I wouldn't be so sure about some on your list.

Deebo was the doctor - he was clearly murdered by the Penguin. Pingu is the most noteable crime boss in the Batman stories, so I'd definitely say that was the night Mafia kill.

JC - you were targeted by the Joker, and the painted faced maniac with the baseball bat was clearly Harley Quinn - they COULD be mafia also, but I think they may be serial killers. Someone saved you, which is telling, or you could have saved yourself?

Tim-Time's and ODWC's write ups look the same, so I'd say they were targeted by the same person - although very strange how both of them managed to survive.

 

I hate when my reasonable doubt lets me down. I should've just voted for Cookie.

I won't role claim yet but town will benefit greatly from having me around soon enough

 

I'm positive TT and ODWC were targeted by the same person.

The write ups definitely share similarities, although one thing that's just jumped out at me is - ODWC was targeted coming back from the funeral of Scotia (town).

TT was just "out and about".

 

Its still a worrying question to ask. In the earlier games it would have possibly seen you lynched tbh. Now it just gets added to the other wee things that gets noticed.

 

I'm not sure about those on the list just trying to narrow it down with what we know.

The only reason I thought Mafia for the attempt on me is because there were two of them and the attempts on TT & ODWC were lone attackers. I'm trying not to look too deep into the characters at the minute as the Grey Ghost claim has shown.

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

Yeah I didn’t actually think anything of it but now see it looks dodgy.

 

Aye that's a fair point - the Gray ghost claim definitely threw me. Simply because I'd never heard of it, then upon researching the character, said he was deemed to be guilty, then proven innocent - which clearly wasn't the case in Keano's depiction.

One thing's for sure, the amount of survivals already is very puzzling indeed. Think we've actually had more successful survivals than deaths? I wouldn't be taking all those survivals as confirmation that those who were saved are automatically Town though, maybe apart from yourself as you clearly survived an attempt on yer life by the Joker and Quinn.

 

I would expect it, its a super hero draft, all hard as *, I know I have a bulletproof on top of my ability so would expect others to.

 

Interesting.

And, yes, Keano seems to have given out a helluva lot of roles that come with bulletproof, well......according to some of the role claims anyway.

 

I wouldn't make the list that long tbh.

While it has been asked and answered I am still unsure how come @Our Eddie felt he could trust Dazza to be worthy of saving ? Or have I missed something here ?
I admit my knowledge on the whole batman and characters could be written on the back of an envelope. The batman I watched was from the 70's and I think i watched one of the "newer" one's from the 90's, Michael Keaton I think it was. I was surprised at my character's name as an example of that tbh.

 

Eddie said he was TOLD Dazza would be getting targeted - I assume via PM as part of his night role? Also, Dazza was targeted by someone with a baseball bat. We've now seen JC targeted also with a baseball bat - although this time the description was it was by a painted faced maniac, along with a laughing man.

can only be these two:

 

I'll continue my 'hard on' then.

Vote Tim Time

 

Is this a genuine vote based on the fact you think he's scum, or that he's said you have a hard on for him?

 

He's scum, mate.

 

I'm inclined to believe you, because I've a good feeling I can trust you're Batman.

I think you know why

 

Vote: Tim Time

 

Why do you think this?

 

Tim not voting for Cookie was indeed one of the ones who stood out to me too. But I'm not sure we can just go through the game with Minty saying 'I'm Batman he's scum' ..might need a bit more tbh..

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

That's what I mean we have Eddies word on it, which given he has claimed superman and as it hasn't been counterclaimed we need to believe that I guess, but how did Eddie know at that point Dazza was worth saving ? That's what I don't get ?
As I said I don't know enough about the possible characters (maybe that makes a difference) so as I wont be spending hours researching them I need to trust you * being right, which makes this game even more confusing.

So you suspect me because I was acting scummy towards Business Hawk, Yea I suppose I was if scummy is asking him 3 times if he had 2 factions to choose from and then removing my vote to allow him some more time to defend himself... aye real scum behaviour that is.

You have said that we should be cautious and not rush to lynch but you have admitted to taking a pot shot at Eddie ... bit of a contradiction that is. While I have no reason to disbelieve you are batman (there could be irony coming here but heyho) as no-one else has counter claimed it. All I can say just now is try and not * this up for town as you are all over the place here. Before you settled on me you had shot at Eddie, suspected Summer Time and Idioteque but you are urging caution. Nightmare

Is there a character that can imitate others ?

 

Interesting couple of pages chat here.

Especially since Deebo was lynched during the night....