[Mafia] Lord of the Greatest Idea Mafia - Orcs win

Yeah but even though you proved you were day vig that doesn't explain how you killed bob after you were protected from Tim's attempt at Killin you.

 

Either

cookie survived Tim's kill (due to Aidan's protection) as scum dayvig and used his faction kill to get Bob

Or summer survived Tim's kill as bulletproof scum, and used his faction kill to get Bob

That's the way the write up reads, someone surviving then going out and killing

Cena is also saying he died on that night, but I can't get his story to fit the narrative... Is it possible Cena is Judas rather than saulus? Someone mentioned gollum earlier

 

I don't agree with all the role reveals. It was scum I was trying to convince I had more power so they would go for me hopefully instead of picking a town power role.

 

Read back and got Cena to fit

Or Cena was Mafia saulus, sent in his night action to kill Bob, simultaneously got killed by Tim and turned to town



Out of the 3 I trust summer the most

 

I had no kill power.

 

If you were part of a faction you would have, eg if you were bulletproof Mafia or bulletproof sk

 

Fair enough. But you can't if you're bulletproof town.

 

Just exploring all of the options. I distrust Cena the most because of his dodgy character claim. I also distrust cookie because he's the only one where there is evidence that fits into mintys write up - we know Aidan saved cookie that night

 

first up aye you are still steaming to come up with that pile of crap .
break it up into paragraphs , 1st one , mumble jumble ..pish. 2nd one .course we backed you on aidan you bullshitted us .. fekkin embarrassing it was . 3rd one , shut up an sit in the corner you are done in this game .4th one , trust the 2 guys still with big roles , good move I trust them as well, scotia no claimed yet is summer Frodo don't think the lads buy that either .

cena is bull... whits the matter can he no help you ,I'm town ... naw yer no .

 

just remembered cena/saulus , that wiki report says town would not be told of cennas change and with tim dieing he wouldn't have been able to point us that was who he targeted . cenna could well be town now . amazing what a sleep can do .

 

So, is cookie prime suspect now or cena?
@ herculepoirotcsc. Aka @Scotia
@Dazza

 

read that wiki again , cenna couldn't name who the mafia were as its a judas role and they would have been replaced , not absolving him here tho . when I was mafia I wanted to win and when I got caught I still wanted them to win so for me cenna deep down still favours mafia and that's where cookie comes in !!!!


lads as usual I'm off at half ten , hot meals round for the auld folk and wont be back until half twoish .

 

was doing that as you posted . for me cookie as cenna converted has no night kill surely .

taking a leap of faith on you summer .

 

I'm working till 5 so won't be on till then i honestly urge you to look elsewhere if i was a scum faction why would i be giving up this information about who mafia targeted. There was only 2 of us so that means at least 1 werewolf or another alien perhaps even both can those factions have day vigs if not then that rules out cookie. Eddie and Summer are still suspect though

 

So we have cena, summer and cookie all who could have been the killer of Bob.

I still think it's cookie, as I said yesterday. Lynch him and if he flips scum we know cena is also a liar.

 

2nd one That's what * happened go back and check, he made a move that made zero sense and outed himself when there was no need. I thought he was lying as did others. Sorry I got it wrong but that's the whole point of the * game, you never * it up in a mafia game?

Nah I think i'll actually make sure town win, but cheers for the tip.

Once again you are barking up the wrong tree and believing the wrong person, but sure go ahead and lynch a townie. You've still not revealed your role, character and discarded character. If you said it's a small role then it will only do you good to reveal.

 

Scotia has claimed unlynchable townie, samwise I believe ?

 

Yep here is his claim

 

Ahh okay my fault never seen that, sorry Scotia.
Going to grab some food and coffee then read back again.

 

Well you'll have to convince me

Vote cookie