Mafia 15 - Bhoy School Reunion

I ain't saying you are Mafia but I am saying it's possible for that scenario to be used. As I said I know I ain't insane.

 

Why?

 

Baffling how several people have blatantly ignored the fact I actually gave SEVERAL reasons as to why I thought Scotia was probably Mafia.

It wasn't a random guess ffs and I didn't know he was Mafia, I'm just occasionally able to read when a player is Mafia.

Aidan was apparently '99%' sure Scotia was Mafia having initially voted for him 'to just go for it' yet I am the one who guessed???

 

It's not possible in this game because I didn't do it. If anything Aidan did it with his '99%' bullshit which you've conveniently ignored btw.

Mafia is either Bob and Aidan or Tim and Aidan.

 

We've never had a game with a Mafia roleblocker and not a godfather.

 

Tim or Bob = David Murray.

Aidan = Nacho Novo.

 

I guessed though...

 

Been looking at this. If the roles are more correlated with the characters than I originally thought, then a well powered Lisbon Lion makes sense.

Bob said with extreme confidence he wouldn't be lynched when I previously pursued him. I pursued him because of Cena's investigation. Now that we know Cena is insane cop, I think Bob has quite strong town cred. There's always that doubt about him being the godfather, but so far we know mafia had a doctor and a roleblocker. A godfather would be way OP, so there's a chance there isn't one at all.

Plenty of time until the deadline, so I urge everyone who is town not to rush the lynch.

We're on a good run at the moment, and I think there's someone who has let themselves slip as mafia on D2. Spent some time reading the thread and got a good idea of who I think is a mafia member.

 

I haven't conveniently forgot what Aidan has said (see my post from when I went out) however I aint talking to him. You should park the ego and drop the insane bullshit as that doesn't help.

Anyway gonna leave this for tonight as we do need to get this right.

 

Sorry mate, but that means * all.

 

Who?

 

Off to bed now. Will double check tomorrow when I'm less tired. Don't want to make an * of myself.

 

It doesn't help when supposed townies post * daft theories that don't even have the slightest credibility when we're trying to find the remaining Mafia.

I know what Obaf was saying a few games ago now about getting frustrated with these games. Read posts, suspect someone of being Mafia, highlight this and give reasoning (twice) and still have two people suggesting I'm Mafia..

Either yous are both Mafia (you and Aidan) and are at it or are just way, way over thinking it to the point it's just stupid.

 

Happened to me again this time mate

I feel your pain mate

 

Tim or Bob are Mafia Godfather. It's obvious.

 

The "99%" post from Aidan is suspicious to me as well.

When I voted Scotia, I was nowhere near sure he'd come back as mafia, all I was sure about was that his style/attitude was completely different.

Aidan hasn't played that many games (neither have I though tbh), so I'd be surprised if that was what made him "99% sure". Even at that, it's hardly hard hitting evidence to be so sure.

Also note, he was 99% Scotia was mafia - Not an SK, not another faction.

He's either mafia or just made a bit of an * of it with that post.

 

Why TT?

 

Because I don't think they both have the roles they are claiming to have, and both came back as bad to Cena who we have concluded is the insane cop. So I think one is Godfather.

I also have an element of trust towards all of Cena, Summer, Obaf and Minty. I haven't had much of a read on yourself to be fair, but I am convinced Aidan is Mafia and Bob or Tim are the Godfather.

 

I wasn't even 99% sure ffs and I started the whole thing on him. I was confident of him but I've gotten others wrong that I was just as confident on so I can never be 100%.

That was clearly a Mafia slip up by him, IMO.

 

I'm reading through day two to try and pick up on what Minty is talking about, and have noticed this.

I'm bolloxed tired so could be reading this totally wrong but it's as though Idioteque knew Bob was lying 'claiming the kill and nobody else claiming it seems believable'.

Could that not be interpreted as Idioteque did the kill, knew Bob was lying but obviously couldn't say so?

The main reason I believed Bob was the way the write up was written, but at this stage of the game we didn't know there was a SK so Eddie might not have wanted to give it away in his write up.