[Mafia] Mafia 10 - Revenge of the Mafia

*, thought this was starting today. lots to catch up on. VT again. Still haven't been mafia in any game.

 

Buddying up to Che ... noted

VT obviously.

 

I think Che will be targeted or investigated/protected in the night phase and if he survives will be lynched the next day anyway.. this is counterproductive to the Town and a waste of night actions.

I remember after the Mafia Brothers game I was lynched straight away due to lack of trust and I was the Town Doctor. Nothing personal against Che but I think it's the most common sense approach for the Town at this stage. And you never know he may be Mafia..
Vote:Che

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

I should add when I was Town Doctor I didn't really get a chance to role claim- so if Che gets to L-1 he should get that opportunity..

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

Really not liking this logic.

How can you know anything about what is or isn't going to happen in the night phase? Voting someone on the previous game is nonsense.

VOTE ANTON

 

I agree with bob, the way anton has basically said we need to kill che for no other reason that he had a good game last time is suspect.

As I said in my last post che had a really good town game last time by exposing mafia. We should give him the chance to do it this time.

Not voting just yet but will more than likely be voting anton after I get home and watch game of thrones.

 

Fair enough, but I'd say it's a certainty that Che will be a focal point after his excellent performance in the last game. The Mafia will want to take out an astute Townie and if he's Mafia it would be an excellent first kill..

He's admitted as much himself.. I just feel keeping him in the game until the inevitable is a waste of Town actions and time, it's obvious that others feel the same.

 

It's not just because he had a good game, its human nature to be wary of him after that game. As I said when I had a good game I was lynched immediately in the game straight after and I expected it..

Players with night actions will be eager to investigate him or protect him, I think that's a waste personally as he will surely be lynched early regardless.

To me it makes perfect sense and only have the Towns best interests at heart. And he may be Mafia too.

 

I see both sides arguments, but for me because it's almost always the same people who play its gonna get to a point where we are gonna start lynching one another off previous games constantly which kind of takes away the point of playing. Che is a good player, as are you Jc along with many others, however I won't be voting for you'se based off what you've done on previous games

 

Fair enough..

We need a starting point tho and for me that is as good as any.

 

so basically we,ve got hee haw to go on so far lads , I'm off to watch game of thrones then last episode of ripper street .

 

Making a lot of excuses up not be playing, starting to remind me of me, first its golf now its ripper street and game of thrones...

 

This is the only post jumping out at me so far to be honest. Not convinced Che would post something like this if he was a town player.

 

Well at least it's more logical thinking as opposed to just voting for some poor * in the first round simply to get a quick kill

 

I'd have expected you to be far more defensive here in all honesty, maybe looks like you're looking for the sympathy vote here, rather than the vote.

Vote Che

 

Why will Che be lynched early regardless? Or do you mean night killed?

I know I've pointed out his post just there, but I think voting for him based on a previous game would be ridiculous.

Also - why would night actions on him be a waste? If he's town and is protected surely that's not a waste.

 

I have to say, that is a very unusual/out of character start to the game from Anton.

Normally urges caution on a first day lynch and is now pushing one based on a previous game?

 

Vote Anton

 

No I'd say he probably won't be night killed if he's Town.. but I reckon he will be lynched early..

 

All over the place here, Deebo....