[Mafia] Mafia 9 - Town win

Something has been niggling me about Che too.. if he was given an 'open role back up', that is at the moderators discretion. Why wasn't he given the role of Town Cop when Summer died? With a Jailkeeper and a Doctor already in play as protecting roles, surely a new Cop in Town would have been the way to go.

Also why vote to lynch the Doctor when you know you're probably back up to that role?

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

actually JC I don't think many at all , looking there I voted cena at the beginning when we were trying to get the ball rolling but we fell short by one for a kill , keano vt and oba godfather were killed at night . looking at the list above I'm pretty sure I didn't vote any of them , couple of votes I missed and others if its casting votes I very rarely done that in any game.
just noticed looking at that dead list that's the last 2 kills been townies and 3 out the last 4 , fer fek sake don't make me 3 in a row as a night kill will make it 4.
you usually are a good reader of these games but if you are town look over again please.

who do I think to vote ..

Scotia , no him obviously hes VT
Cenna , far too quiet in this game and why did he get voted for 1st kill again ? must have been a reason.
The Greenman , has a role so it cant be him then
JC , ok I,ll believe you , but you've done me over in previous games .
Che , going to be up there with the best liars in the game if he's not back up role .


So , Cenna is the most likely as so far he's not made a convincing case for being townie.


Then again in the last couple of days ive swung from bob to che to jc to now cenna, I might be no the best at this game but if someone believes me its a start to winning this .

 

I think we may have found the Mafia and it's a serial killer we're looking for now.. hunt the Mafia and then pick off the Town one by one..
Vote:Che

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

I'm stuck between scotia and che

 

I'm reading back here , trying to find out who killed who ,

keano -vt - first mafia hit
oba - godfather same night , we still don't know who ?
sean - mafia - jacked it in .. conveniently
summertime - cop - mafia hit
ourdaywillcome - vt - town lynch
deebo - mafia roleblocker - town lynch
bob- town commuter - town lynch
v - mafia - town lynch
idioteque - doctor -town lynch
Larsson - vt - mafia kill

hope that's right I'm no reading 60 pages again .

how many nights no mafia kill ? ( not a bad thing but why ? )
jailer said he jailed me on night 6 and I know I cant kill anyone but still no mafia kill after idio was killed that day even after he disclosed his role .

mafia not pressing their advantage a few times ... why ?

who's protecting who here ?

two confirmed roles left but one is a traitor to the town or both !

I realise ive completed the circle now in suspecting greenman but the only thing I know is .... I know your fed up hearing it .

 

If

If I were a serial killer I would not have targeted mafia and I wouldn't have claimed a role. It makes no sense.

I would have let mafia do the killing and sat back to watch.

If it is a serial killer and not mafia then you would be a prime candidate. Would the serial killer come back to the cop as town?

I think it would. I have baded your innocence on Summers posts. I still hope it is mafia though which can only mean Scotia for me.

Vote scotia

 

right I'm off shortly to finish that wee job I started yesterday , ive read a lot of pages this morning , jumped from suspect to suspect and I wish youse could see my notepad with all my scribbles and notes fekkin loony I know . the thing that stands most out to me is Che's delivery of the last vote on Idioteque even after he role claimed the doctor then claimed that was the role he was back up to , seems too convenient after other roles were killed off.

vote Che ( claims to have played a big part in deebos and V's lynches and did but if it turns out he had prior knowledge of his compatriots roles and has a solo role he killed the godfather )

I think greenman is involved as well somewhere , a look at his claimed jailed list on what nights would be handy .

 

was typing that as you posted so not a response .

 

Who killed the Godfather then? Killed with a blade the preferred weapon of a serial killer..

If The Greenman is telling the truth I was jailed so couldn't kill. You know I'm Town..





Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

makes plenty sense if you have the option to win alone .

I might be wrong and generally am but the godfather killing suggests to me a renegade mafia .. you !!

third line ive no idea what that point is

vote scotia .... touched a nerve somewhere have I ?

 

There was nothing about "open role backup". It was merely "Role Backup". I had no indication as to what the role I was backing up would be until Idioteque was lynched. As far as I knew it was as likely Bob, Greenmans or Idioteques role I could have taken. I assume Minty knew from the start what role I would be taking was, but I didn't

 

greenman says he jailed me on night 6 JC the day idioteque was lynched , no mafia kill that night after a confirmed role of ours was killed .. why ? yes yadda yadda I know I cant kill anyone at anytime in this game other than when I vote to lynch .... well unless minty pm's me with a mythical role today I cant .

 

Do you agree it would have made more sense to have you back up to the Town Cop tho, unless The Greenman is lying about being the Jailkeeper? He was last to role claim wasn't he? And it's easy to say you protected someone when their still alive the next day.

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

* never thought of that .

 

You haven't touched any nerve with me. It is merely a game. I don't take personal issues.

The point I was making that you didn't grasp..
If you aren't mafia, and I suspect you are, then I think it must be a serial killer. I have based Antons innocence on the fact that Summer said he was town - but if Summer investigated him and he was a serial killer would the result come back to Summer as "town"?

He would appear innocent of being mafia but his true role would be hidden. Merely a theory at this point but I would prefer the lynch on you as mafia as I still think that is what the evidence points too. If Anton is a serial killer he has played a blinder tbf.

 

In hindsight I should have listened to Bob. He said that nurse and doctor as he called them, akways went together - but I suspected Bob and toom what he said as being meant to disrupt. When we lynched him I thought we had won and was incredibly surprised that he was indeed the commuter. Biggest mistake I made in the game I think

 

fair enough but your theory is completely wrong on me Che .

ive really got to go now guys and this is fekkin doing my head in , I cant convince youse so ,

unvote che

that's 2 on me now so somebody do the third please !!

town will be sorry .

 

If Scotia is simply Mafia, who killed The Godfather?
And remember I was jailed last night and there was still a kill, so coupled with Summertime's investigation it surely confirms me as Town.

Sent from my HTC Desire 530 using Tapatalk

 

If Greenman is indeed the jailkeeper then that boosts your credentials for sure. The hit on Obaf has confused me ever since. I can't get a read on it and that worries me

 

2 votes for Scotia: Greenman, Che
1 vote for Che: JC Anton

Takes 3 to lynch.