[Mafia] Mafia 8 - The mafia return

I get this theory and at this stage of the game it's probably as good as any.. however we say KILL to each other in lots of other threads when the game isn't being played. I killed TimTime in the Mafia chat room during the brothers game and type that now and again remind him. So it's easy for people who haven't played before to pick that up.

But like I say it's as good as any theory at this stage.

 

I'm not gonna be on for pretty much all of today, on a course in * Liverpool

 

After having a read back Bogunda is definitely mafia. He was one of the ones who voted for Bob which puts him under suspicion right away as the Mafia probably had at least 2 of them voting for him. Also Bob who we now know was town was suspicious of him. But the real evidence is when he said 'kill borobob' (which is exactly what the Mafia say in their chat when they've decided on who to kill) instead of 'vote borobob'. He also hasn't played before which makes it impossible for him to know that's what the Mafia say, unless of course he is Mafia now. If he had played before as mafia I might be able to give him the benefit of the doubt on that but he hasn't so no. Another piece of evidence against him is that he's playing dumb and using the "i haven't played before" excuse to deflect away from whenever anyone gets suspicious of him which is exactly what I did the first time I played when I was mafia and it worked right until the very end. So for those reasons vote Bogunda

Also Cena is worrying me as well. I would've voted for him if it wasn't so obvious Bogunda is Mafia.

 

Is this about me saying I was a chocolate townie at the start? It was just a wee joke about a previous game I've already told you that. I'll admit I * up on voting for Bob though but he was a goner anyway.

 

As you are aware from SongQuest I said I was away this weekend and that would obviously see me on here less so making an issue of that is strange. As for me spreading confusion I haven't named anyone who may be mafia but funnily enough you are with me (see above and below posts) and poster already ,while my posts are pointing out something that may well help us find the mafia in terms of voting patterns.

Anyway
I can see why people suspect Padmill ,as Kill is what the mafia are told to PM. However for now I won't vote as we have till Monday so let's try and get this one right given we have already lost a valuable power role.

 

Cmon mate we have a mountain of evidence against him here compared to what we usually have. Usually we only have a few comments that don't add up or some misplaced votes if we're lucky. What do you really think could happen between now and the deadline which will make anyone more suspicious than him?

 

Carry on son, carry on...

 

Vote Bogunda Bath
Think he slipped up on with the kill option. I didn't pick up on that as I've never been mafia and didn't know what messages you get sent. Well spotted.

 

Oh right, and what exactly is this mountain of evidence?

 

You quoted it a minute ago

 

What's the vote stand at?
On phone so struggling to work out.

 

3 for Bogunda and 1 for Greenman, I think.

 

4 for Bogunda 1 for me and 1 for lavender

 

Tbf I never noticed you saying you'd be away and on less..

 

I did not quote a "mountain" of evidence

 

What I posted about you is a mountain of evidence by mafia standards. Anyway I won't be replying to you in this thread anymore you're clearly mafia. Everyone else can look at the evidence and make their own minds up.

 

I was suspicious of him yesterday and this seals it for me. The gaffe reminds me of how Summer accidentally voted and unvoted for the first person the Mafia killed in the first game we played

vote: Bogunda

 

What I would say having been Mafia before is that it's easy to sit back and watch the Town vote for each other and you certainly can't look at voting patterns this early in the game.

Having Borobob and Bogunda going at each other straight away, coupled with Scotia exposing himself as the Jailkeeper is a dream start for them.

I think if Bogunda was Mafia he may have played it a bit more cautiously and remember one of his first questions was 'How do we know who's who?' If he were Mafia he would know that remember, so either he's Town or has picked up the game very quickly.

I know if he is Mafia people will look at this post, we just need to get this one right or we will be four Town down.

 

Cheers

 

How many are needed for lynching this time?