The Mystery of Paul Hartley?

Danny Bhoy strikes the nail on the head

 

Ayep!

he actually does * our whole formation up... why pay 4.5 million for a class player then play him out of position to accomodate this idiot. a nonsense.

was in san siro and Evander Sno was immense. what must he be feeling that he gets on bench behind hartley? sno has potential.. hartley is done. finished.

i'm more than willing to give him a lift up the M8... even though i'm too young to drive.

 

I really wish we never went in for Hartley and let him go to rangers.

 

Exactly
Its the same as Steven Gerard being played on the right wing . GS is playing our best player out of position .

Sno is one of the best young talents in the world game
As is Brown ...i think in 2-3 years the way the market is going we could get 15-20million for these lads theyre that good . Not that i want to sell them but i think thats their market value

 

paul hartley strikes me as a small fish in a big pond now. I think we have made a mistake by signing him and i would happily see him go. yes theres always going to be occassions where players start well and dip in performance after that. miller as an example but i still like him and think he will turn it round BUT hartley i think simply isnt good enough and is a mistake for strach

 

I wonder if George Burley would take him to Southampton

 

personally, i would be suprised if sno amounted to much.
i was a big fan of his when he came but he looks the sort that will get caught out far too easy alot of the time, i know hes only 7 or somthing right now but i dont thik he will amount to much

 

Who else thought the officiating was not up to scratch??

 

me, but i dont like to comment on it unless we won as it seems like an excuse.

 

I think Sno and Brown would be a very good balanced central midfield. Not sure Brown and Donati are a defensive enough combination against top teams. There was a big hole in front of the defense where Lenny used to stand against killie. Reckon we will have a 4-5-1 in Moscow with

.................jvoh

aidan...donati....sno/hartley....brown...naka

 

Thats why were paranoid
Thats why were paranoid

Great chant

 

Are you for real?

 

just watched the whole first half again, and tbh, hartley did well.
took a crap free kick and put the ball over from out side the box but constenty winning headers, made two good tackles to stop killes attack deep in the celtic half.
held players off the ball

naylor, was shocking. imo naylor rating 4, hartley 6

 

It's McGeady people should be going on about. Can't stand the player. You get the feeling when he has the ball that he will do * all with it, or fluff a shot, the greedy wee * that he is. Riordan is much better. If I was Riordan I would be extremely frustrated and I won't be surprised if he seeks a transfer.

Hartley was okay yesterday, certainly better than some other players, though he still has to perform.

 

if you want to point the finger point it at the gaffer for starting magic what a * joke that was,deek should have been partnering jvoh.

we've discussed this many times before but it is true wgs tactics are * * and if we play like this against moscow we will get humped.

 

Don't think McGeady like Miller is ever going to make the grade...neither of them can finish what they start

 

Before Pressley and Hartley signed from Hearts, I said they are going to be bad signings. I hated it when Pressley played for Scotland and he is so careless and slow. I hate when Nakamura isn't playing and Hartley takes the set pieces for us. Why???? He wastes 99.9% of his corners and freekicks. So why does he take them. Also I think the Celtic midfield lacks a Attacking Midfielder who breaks forward. Basically we haven't replaced the vacant position that has been left since Petrov left. Hopefully Brown will prove that he is the man to fill this position but GS has to avoid playing him on the wing and play him and Donati central

 

The midfield should be Mcgeady, Donati, Brown, Naka. In Naka's absence then Hartley should not be put on. Our central midfield must stay Donati, Brown. If you need to switch McGeady to the right and play Deeks on the left or vice versa.

 

Yes im 100% real
If you watched him you will see he has the physical strengh in the middle of the park and he adapted well to the Scottish game last season . Sno was even called up to the Dutch squad for the friendly against England . I dont know why people ( not you ) knock a 20 year old who had a fantastic debut season and could at Celtic Par develop into a world beater

 

Magic's had it he's not impressed me at all since his 1st season.

As for Hartley well i've already expressed opinions on him in previous threads, although if he went i doubt very much we would miss him.

15-20million? rubles?