Celtic's Best Signing?

Who do we all think is celtic best signing so far?
personally i think scott brown.
has looked the strongest so far.

 

Can't say yet mate theres been no real indication yet

 

unanswerable..... ask this at xmas and we may have a clue.

 

brown has looked full of energy and given us a bit of drive and donati has looked tidy but as tiesto posted its a bit early yet,ill vote for brown though

 

we've played 3 friendlies..

 

2 Friendlies

 

3 friendlies? Who was the third against? And I'm gonna say Donati although we'll only really know in May 2008.

 

Way way to early to say. Only when we have played real games will we be able to tell.

 

Brown, he always seems ready for a fight! True hoop!

 

I think Broonaldo as he has shown what he can do for Hibs already.
Donati will be a great addition to the squad and give us some technical wizardry in the middle, no doubt.

 

too early to decide ...

 

Brown has showen potential and so has donati but post this thread again in 2/3 months then we can say who has been the best summer signing

 

i think brown will be a good player for us next season. so i voted him, but no one can really say at this stage.

 

If JVoH ends up injured as much as last season i feel it might turn out to be Killen.

 

I like this mans optimism I voted for Brown cause so far in the friendlies he's looked pretty good. For a more inciteful answer, ask in 8 games into the season.

 

Wise up, Killen?

Let's hope not. Donati is genuine quality, as is Tommy G, although he is playin shockin.

Brown is on the edge of the squad, along wi Sno, who has technical quality the is missing in a lot of Scots.

 

I chose Killen because we got him on a free, are paying him quite small wages and i think we will be pleasantly surprised by his contribution. Due to the fees attached to Brown and Donati they have to play out of their skins to be regarded as good buys. Obviously folk are going to say Brown because he cost the most but if you mean by 'best' you mean clever or value for money i think Killen may we surprise a lot of folk. He was going great guns for Hibs before he got injured last season.

 

I think the thread is what signing is going to preform best this season not what signing will prove value for money.

And why does everyone think Jvoh is injury prone ?

 

Killen is nothing but a sub for JVOH, we shouldn't be signin subs, Suttster was better by far, but WGS saw himn as a threat to his style, so he let him go for FA. Killen is back up for JVOH, who couldn't lace his boots.

I' m more excited about McDonald, pace, with a little bit of finishin ability, Miller could learn alot!

I don't think Donati will have to play ouot of his skin to match his 3m tag, watchin him so far, I thinnk he is quality.
In addition, I think Sno has great potential. He'd be captain if not injured.