Would you offer Boruc for Keane?

Keene isnt a goal keeper and is owned by spurs so whats the question

 

No, keane is obliged to leave celtic when his loans up,as he keeps saying "ill be at tottenham next season" and as far as i know Boruc loves celtic, and hes great.

 

we should do anything to keep keane tbh

 

It's a hypothetical question. Purely for the purpose of discussion.

 

See aforementioned post.

 

Nope.

So frustrating watching hard work undone by incompetent keepers in recent years. For all his ups and downs, Boruc is our most talented/reliable in a long time.

Plus Keane has no value to resell, Boruc is only a bit younger, but keepers go for longer.

 

yes-boruc is past it for me. zaluska can do just as good.

 

I think theres more chance of McGeady being swapped for Keane

 

Now there is a deal I would go for!

 

Too right mate...We get Keane for 3/4 years Mcgeady goes down south for 3/4 but doesn't do as good as expected he wants to come home so we sign him back ....LOL

 

NO WAY. Fair enough Keane has scored a few, but how many chances does he need. He had umpteen against Hearts at parkhead. He specialises in hitting the keepers legs. Would have no problems if he went back just now. Would be gutted to see Artur leave

 

Cant believe this really ,players normally take a bit of time to settle in but Keane took what 2 games and hasnt stopped scoring since ,i reckon he could well score 20 before the season ends ,thats some going for someone who arrived in January.

 

No. Trading in a good goalie with years in the tank (goalies have far longer career) for a 30 year old striker is bad business. If Keane had been 27 I would have said yes but at 30 a striker will devalue quickly. Most in England think Keane is past his best now and on the slide. If Artur is worth the 7-8 million people claim (I doubt it personally) then that is too much to trade in for a striker about to head over the hill. Its the one position where most (spare me a list of exceptions) are on the slide once they ate in their early 30s. If we sell Artur, I would like to see the money going towards two excellent players not from the inflated prices of the EPL. I am sure a Keane standard striker can be got on the continent for 5 million. Keane is simply not worth the 8 million pounds+ you hear suggested. Best avoid the EPL IMO.

 

hhaahaha thats mental cant beleive your been serious

 

30 goals a season for the next 4 years would do me fine he would achieve this no problem while imo Boruc is replaceable .

 

Both world class like though, no doubting that!

Would be great to have them both next year!

 

neither are world class

 

Care to name one?

 

Ofcourse.

 

I would definately entertain it.. Hard to say who'd get the best deal..

Keane's age does play a part in it but we need "clinical" players for next season and Keane fits the bill.. Could probably play on for another 5 years in some capacity (See Kevin Phillips) , while it could go either way for Boruc if he went to Spurs , could be found wanting even more from his kicking when being closed down by Drogba , Torres , Rooney etc , or he could turn in a fantastic season or two and then get a Shay-Given-Esque move to a top four club for £10m+..
A solid defence in the SPL shouldn't need a potential world class goalkeeper behind it...
I'd be willing to take the gamble that having Keane would mean gaining more points through scoring goals , than points being dropped through Boruc being moved on..