IS KEANE IN THE SAME BRACKET AS LARSSON AND JINKY

You'll still prob have a job on your hands trying to convince 'robbie keanes no1 fan' lol

 

keano wud laugh his own head off at being compared to larsson , keanes a top drawer striker , larssons world class

 

And he still cant lace Jimmy's boot's.:icon_mrgreen:

 

aye i voted wee jinky aswell.

Didnt grow up in that generation but ive seen plenty of clips of him , twisting and turning.. leaving defenders on their holes every time he got the ball to feet.

My da was a big fan of wee jinky and george best

 

Whe you get 135,000 Real Madrid fans on there feet shouting OLE every time you touched the ball ,your doing something right and Jimmy tore that team to ribbons that night.

 

yup seen that footage a lot!! that would have been special as a player hearing that there

 

everytime i look at the title of this thread when i click into celtic chat ,i have to laugh at it .jinky,larson,keane

 

no comparison,,,,larrson was a legend always will be ,
jinky was one of a kind ,

keane could be good but only time will tell if hes commited to us then he can put his name on the list of legends at our special club heirarcy.

 

I can see your a new signing, your obviously going to be a bundle of laughs, never the less welcome.

 

spot on

 

Robbies got to earn his stripes

Robbie has gotta earn his stripes- at the moment and I have said it before he reminds me of Bellamy who I rate mega highly too!

Henrik is a legend- enough said

 

a big up for robbie. but this question would have to be asked 7 years from now{in comparisson to henrik]
and as regards to wee jinky?robbies own dad is quoted as
being the best player he had ever seen in a celtic shirt

 

Personally I think Henrik is far better. However, sometimes trophies and goals scored can mislead you on how good a player is. Boyd has been top goalscorer in Scotland over recent years but no one could say he was as good a player than Sutton for example.

Henrik was a BIG GAME player, Robbie has still to do anything like that for us. Keane is far better than Kris Boyd, but Boyd has won more league championships. The only way I could even think of comparing the 2 is if Robbie was here as long as Henrik and that's just not going to happen.

 

dont mean to be a party pooper i like robbie keane but got a major feeling rasmussen will have a better influence in the season stats dont tell lies morten has scored more

 

To be honest, and this is going to make me unpopular I'm sure, Boyd is a nice player. If we all like big Razz then how can we so undervalue Boyd. He's not Henrik and I dislike him as a Rangers player... but come on. He has taken 1/3 of his chances this year for goals. I know he hasn't scored against us (but he has hardly played against us either). I'm not saying he's the greatest, but he's not the slouch everyone on these boards make him out to be....



Henrik is still a vastly superior player in all aspects, but there's no real shame in that if you are Boyd, methinks.

 

boyd is great unless you want to win games in europe in which case he's useless

 

This topic headline is a little unclear. Does the poster mean is Keane on par with Larsson and Jinky Celtic-legend wise or ability wise? He is defo not a legend (yet) and ability wise...don't think he is as good as Larsson or Jinky either. Sorry! But it can also be argued he played on a higher level of football regulary but Larsson and Jinky destroyed opponents of all sorts of levels!

 

boyd has never scored in a game thats mattered FACT
BY THAT I MEAN TITLE DECIDERS CUP WINS EUROPEAN WINS
* novo has scored more important goals than that *

 

As has Tommy Gravesen

 

nothing misleading about winning trophies at every club you ve been at in the space of 13 years and only winning the league cup and 2 friendly tournaments in 13 years, keane is a decent player but overated, his first spell at spurs was the best he has played since then he has been an average player