IS KEANE IN THE SAME BRACKET AS LARSSON AND JINKY

Man * are you smoking , Think about this now when i spell these nanes out . LARSON,JINKY,KEANE .LOL Hes nowhere on the same level as them 2 and i dont think he could be, even if he was here for 5 years .Your talking about henrik larson and jinky johnstone ffs

 

what people seem to forget is that keanes done nothing so far at celtic. Hes played 1 game. To be comparing him to great celtic players or classing him with ex celtic players is madness.

Roy keane came up with a big big rep, had a great reception by our fans aswell.... had one really gd game against rangers and that was about it. Im not saying robbies gona be like that at all. Im really confident he'll get loads of goals but im reserving judgement till the end of the season to judge his celtic career.

 

hes not yet but hopfully if he signs on the prem deal then he could be :icon_mrgreen:

 

I really hope its not a prem deal he signs next year:icon_mrgreen:

 

Jimmy Johnstone was the best of the lot hands down ,i doubt if Henrik would make my top 5 and Keane could'nt lace Henrik's boots .

 

what a stupid thread

 

With all due respect to Larsson, Jinky has to be the best. I don't know how is Keane regarded as some sort of legend here, he did absolutely nothing for us (yet)! Can't believe how he's hyped as some sort of saviour of ours, he can't do all things on his own, Larsson and John couldn't do it either.

I'm delighted we have player of his profile and caliber, but I think our fans expect too much from him. We're not Robbie Keane FC, we're Celtic FC. If we're to win the league, it will be us and only us, not some individual.

 

You having a * laff.

 

A way and boil yer heid Paul lol.......Na only kidding m8 he's got a long way to go before you can compare......Seemples

 

Not a chance, even if he was to stay here for the next 4 years he wouldn't be anywhere near either Jinky or Henrik. Don't get me wrong, I think Keane is a great player but the other two are legends in the hoops.

I'll judge where he comes in the list of Celtic players after his Celtic career is over, which is unfortunately likely to be in 6 months time.

 

No chance,not a hope is Keane anywhere near as good as Jinky or Henrik.

Even if he did stay for the rest of his career,he would be nowhere near a legend.

Keane is very overated.

 

No chance wont be here long enough simple as that ,

 

rasmussen has a better chance of becoming a legend than keano. and keanos me favorite player

 

Don't think he's gonna be like any of them TBH, for a start Jinky played on the wing and theres only one * and his names Henrik.

 

larsson is a legend and a proven great player.

keane is just a proven great player.

if he signs permanently id tip him to be the next celtic legend

 

i dont think keane will score as many goals as big raz,i think he will get a lot of assists but in the time keanes here i think raz will be the main goal threat.

 

keane isnt even that good at , the most over rated player in scotland by a country mile just because he is irish

 

What are you on

 

Keane could become a Celtic legend no doubt.

If Celtic means that much to him, he'd stay and take a wage cut - simple as that. Would Celtic go for broke and pay the fee to Tottenham, I don't know.

Larsson gave us years of his career when he could have moved onto bigger and higher paying clubs.

 

I think Redknapp might have option to take Boruc or Mcgeady for him at the end of the season who knows